Fıkıh · Oruç, Ramazan ve bayram
Is it allowed to join fasts without breaking them (wisal)?
Dört fıkıh mezhebinin joining fasts (wisal) hakkındaki görüşleri, Kuveyt İslam Fıkhı Ansiklopedisi el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye'den: 29 görüş, her biri ansiklopedinin kendi Arapça ifadesi ve yeriyle.
İngilizce metin, Arapçanın yapay zekâ ile yazılmış ve ona göre otomatik olarak denetlenmiş bir özetidir.
Kendi durumunuz için güvendiğiniz bir âlime sorun.
Genel bakış
Kısaca
- Cumhurdefinition
- Şâfiî (bir görüş)definition
- Hanefî (bir görüş)definition
- Şâfiî (bir görüş)definition
- Cumhur
What is the definition of al-wisal (continuous fasting) according to the majority of jurists? It is fasting for two or more days without breaking the fast in between.
Arapçası
والوصال في الاصطلاح - عند جمهور الفقهاء - هو: أن يصوم يومين فأكثر لا فطر بينهما.
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 1
- Şâfiî (bir görüş)
What is one view among the Shafi‘is on the definition of al-wisal? It is fasting for two or more days without intentionally consuming food at night without an excuse, while intercourse and the like do not prevent wisal.
Geçerli olduğu durum: without intentionally consuming food at night without an excuse
Arapçası
وفي رأي عند الشافعية: أن يصوم يومين فأكثر، ولا يتناول بالليل مطعوما عمدا بلا عذر، فالجماع ونحوه لا يمنع الوصال.
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 1
- Hanefî (bir görüş)
What is the definition of al-wisal according to some Hanafis? It is fasting the entire year without breaking the fast on the prohibited days.
Geçerli olduğu durum: without breaking the fast on the prohibited days
Arapçası
وقال بعض الحنفية: هو أن يصوم السنة كلها ولا يفطر في الأيام المنهي عنها.
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 1
- Şâfiî (bir görüş)
What is the definition of al-wisal according to some Shafi‘is? It is to continuously maintain all the characteristics of those who fast.
Arapçası
وقال بعض الشافعية: هو أن يستديم جميع أوصاف الصائمين.
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 1
Wisal for the Muslim community
Kısaca
- CumhurHanefîMâlikîŞâfiî (bir görüş)Hanbelîdisliked
- Şâfiîforbidden
- Cumhurforbidden
- İttifaklaprohibited
- Diğer âlimlerforbidden for those for whom it is difficult, permissible for those for whom it is not difficult
- CumhurHanefîMâlikîŞâfiî (bir görüş)Hanbelî
Is continuous fasting (al-wisal) permissible for the Muslim community? The majority (Hanafis, Malikis, Hanbalis, and some Shafi'is) hold that continuous fasting is disliked (makruh) for the community.
Geçerli olduğu durum: في حق الأمة
Arapçası
ذهب جمهورهم (الحنفية والمالكية والحنابلة وبعض الشافعية) إلى أن الوصال في الصوم مكروه في حق الأمة
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 2
- Şâfiî
Is continuous fasting (al-wisal) forbidden for the community? The Shafi'is in the most correct view hold that continuous fasting is forbidden (haram) for the community, whether the fast is supererogatory or obligatory, and permissible for the Prophet.
Geçerli olduğu durum: على الأمة - نفلا كان الصوم أو فرضا - مباح له
Arapçası
وذهب الشافعية في الأصح إلى أن الوصال حرام على الأمة - نفلا كان الصوم أو فرضا - مباح له
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 2
- Cumhur
Is continuous fasting (al-wisal) forbidden? Al-Nawawi said that continuous fasting is prohibited, and this is the view of the majority (al-jumhur).
Arapçası
قال النووي: الوصال منهي عنه وهو قول الجمهور
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 2
- İttifakla
Is continuous fasting (al-wisal) prohibited? Al-'Abdari said that the prohibition of continuous fasting is the view of all scholars except Ibn al-Zubayr.
Arapçası
وقال العبدري: إن النهي عن الوصال هو قول العلماء كافة إلا ابن الزبير
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 2
- Diğer âlimler
Is continuous fasting (al-wisal) forbidden for those for whom it is difficult, and permissible for those for whom it is not difficult? Ibn Hajar al-'Asqalani said: It is said that it is forbidden for the one for whom it is difficult, and permissible for the one for whom it is not difficult.
Geçerli olduğu durum: على من شق عليه، ويباح لمن لم يشق عليه
Arapçası
وقال ابن حجر العسقلاني: وقيل: يحرم على من شق عليه، ويباح لمن لم يشق عليه
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 2
Wisal for the Prophet ﷺ
Kısaca
- Cumhurpermissible (mubah)
- Diğer âlimlerrecommended (mustahabb)
- Cumhur
Is continuous fasting (al-wisal) permissible for the Prophet? The majority of jurists hold that continuous fasting is permissible for the Prophet and is one of his special characteristics.
Geçerli olduğu durum: for the Prophet ﷺ
Arapçası
ذهب جمهور الفقهاء إلى أن الوصال في حق النبي ﷺ: مباح، وهو من خصائصه
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 3
- Diğer âlimler
Is continuous fasting recommended for the Prophet? Imam al-Haramayn and al-Ghazali hold that continuous fasting is recommended (mustahabb) for him.
Geçerli olduğu durum: for the Prophet ﷺ
Arapçası
وقال إمام الحرمين والغزالي: إن الوصال له مستحب
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 3
Joining the fast until suhoor time
Kısaca
- Hanbelînot disliked
- Şâfiînot continuous fasting (laysa bi-wisal)
- Hanbelî
Is continuous fasting until dawn disliked? The Hanbalis state that continuous fasting until dawn is not disliked.
Geçerli olduğu durum: until dawn (al-sahar)
Arapçası
نص الحنابلة على أنه لا يكره الوصال إلى السحر
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 5
- Şâfiî
Does delaying eating until dawn count as continuous fasting? The Shafi'is hold that if one delays eating until dawn for a valid purpose or otherwise, it is not continuous fasting.
Geçerli olduğu durum: if one delays eating until dawn for a valid purpose or otherwise
Arapçası
وقال الشافعية في ذلك: إن أخر الأكل إلى السحر لمقصود صحيح أو غيره فليس بوصال
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 5
Intercourse during wisal
Kısaca
- Cumhurprevents the continuous fast
- Şâfiî (bir görüş)does not remove from the ruling of continuous fasting
- Cumhur
The majority of jurists hold that sexual intercourse during the night of continuous fasting (wisal) prevents the continuous fast.
Geçerli olduğu durum: الجماع في ليل الوصال في الصوم
Arapçası
ذهب جمهور الفقهاء إلى أن الجماع في ليل الوصال في الصوم يمنع الوصال
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 8
- Şâfiî (bir görüş)
Some Shafi‘is hold that sexual intercourse during the night of continuous fasting does not remove one from the ruling of continuous fasting.
Geçerli olduğu durum: الجماع في ليل الوصال
Arapçası
وقال بعض الشافعية: إن الجماع في ليل الوصال لا يخرج من حكم الوصال
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 8
Joining in prayer
Kısaca
- Hanbelîprohibited
- Hanbelîprohibited
- Hanbelîprohibited
- Diğer âlimlermust not connect
- Diğer âlimlermust not connect
- Diğer âlimlermust not connect
- Hanbelî
According to Ahmad ibn Hanbal, the imam is prohibited from connecting his recitation with the takbir of ihram, and from connecting his bowing with his recitation.
Geçerli olduğu durum: للإمام: أن لا يصل قراءته بتكبيرة الإحرام، ولا ركوعه بقراءته
Arapçası
فعلى الإمام من النهي اثنتان ... أن لا يصل قراءته بتكبيرة الإحرام، ولا ركوعه بقراءته
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 9
- Hanbelî
According to Ahmad ibn Hanbal, the follower is prohibited from connecting his takbir of ihram with the imam's takbir, and from connecting his taslim with the imam's taslim.
Geçerli olduğu durum: للمأموم: أن لا يصل تكبيرة الإحرام بتكبيرة الإمام، ولا تسليمه بتسليمه
Arapçası
وعلى المأموم واحدة ... أن لا يصل تكبيرة الإحرام بتكبيرة الإمام، ولا تسليمه بتسليمه
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 9
- Hanbelî
According to Ahmad ibn Hanbal, it is prohibited to connect the first taslim (obligatory) with the second taslim (sunnah) without a separation.
Geçerli olduğu durum: وصل التسليمة الأولى بالثانية
Arapçası
ولا يجمع بين الفرض والسنة
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 9
- Diğer âlimler
According to al-Ghazali, the imam must not connect his recitation with the takbir of ihram, nor his bowing with his recitation.
Geçerli olduğu durum: للإمام: أن لا يصل قراءته بتكبيرة الإحرام، ولا ركوعه بقراءته
Arapçası
اثنان على الإمام: أن لا يصل قراءته بتكبيرة الإحرام، ولا ركوعه بقراءته
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 9
- Diğer âlimler
According to al-Ghazali, the follower must not connect his takbir of ihram with the imam's takbir, nor his taslim with the imam's taslim.
Geçerli olduğu durum: للمأموم: أن لا يصل تكبيرة الإحرام بتكبيرة الإمام، ولا تسليمه بتسليمه
Arapçası
واثنان على المأموم: أن لا يصل تكبيرة الإحرام بتكبيرة الإمام، ولا تسليمه بتسليمه
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 9
- Diğer âlimler
According to al-Ghazali, the obligatory taslim must not be connected with the second taslim; one should separate between them.
Geçerli olduğu durum: وصل تسليمة الفرض بالتسليمة الثانية
Arapçası
وواحدة بينهما: أن لا يصل تسليمة الفرض بالتسليمة الثانية، وليفصل بينهما
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 9
Joining "amin" to the Fatihah
Kısaca
- Şâfiînot said except after al-Fatihah
- Diğer âlimlershould not connect without a pause
- Şâfiîrecommended not to connect, but to pause slightly
- Şâfiî
According to al-Shafi‘i, 'Amin' is not said except after Umm al-Qur'an (al-Fatihah).
Arapçası
قال الشافعي: لا يقال: آمين إلا بعد أم القرآن.
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 11
- Diğer âlimler
According to al-Ghazali, one should not connect 'Amin' to 'wa la al-dallin' without a pause.
Arapçası
وقال الغزالي: لا يصل "آمين" بقوله: (ولا الضالين) وصلا.
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 11
- Şâfiî
According to al-Nawawi, some or a group of our companions (Shafi‘is) hold that it is recommended not to connect the word 'Amin' to 'wa la al-dallin', but rather to make a very slight pause.
Arapçası
وقال النووي: ذكر أصحابنا أو جماعة منهم أنه يستحب أن لا يصل لفظة "آمين" بقوله: "ولا الضالين" بل بسكتة لطيفة جدا
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 11
Joining the recitation to the opening takbir
Kısaca
- Cumhursunnah
- Diğer âlimlershould connect
- Cumhur
The majority of jurists hold that separating the takbirat al-ihram from the recitation of al-Fatihah in prayer by the opening supplication (du‘a’ al-istiftah) is sunnah.
Arapçası
ذهب جمهور الفقهاء إلى أن فصل تكبيرة الإحرام عن قراءة الفاتحة في الصلاة بدعاء الاستفتاح سنة
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 12
- Diğer âlimler
Some other jurists hold that one should connect the recitation directly to the takbirat al-ihram without the opening supplication.
Arapçası
وذهب آخرون إلى الوصل بين القراءة وتكبيرة الإحرام.
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 12
Joining the two salams
Kısaca
- Diğer âlimlersunnah to separate
- Diğer âlimlershould follow by saying taslim after the imam
- Cumhurdoes not harm
- Diğer âlimler
The jurists mention that it is sunnah for the one who performs two taslims at the end of the prayer to exit it to separate between them.
Geçerli olduğu durum: for the one who performs two taslims
Arapçası
ذكر الفقهاء أنه يسن لمن يأتي بالتسليمتين في آخر الصلاة للخروج منها أن يفصل بينهما.
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 13
- Diğer âlimler
The jurists hold that the follower (muqtadi) should follow his imam in the taslim by saying it after him.
Arapçası
وذهب الفقهاء إلى أن المقتدي يتابع إمامه في السلام، بأن يسلم بعده.
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 13
- Cumhur
The majority hold that the follower's taslim coinciding with the imam's taslim does not harm, in general terms.
Geçerli olduğu durum: in general
Arapçası
وقال الجمهور: إن مقارنة المقتدي للإمام في التسليم لا تضر، وهذا في الجملة.
el-Mevsûatü'l-Fıkhiyye, cilt 43, madde «وصال», paragraf 13