Fiqh · Fasting, Ramadan and Eid
I'tikaf: its rulings, and what breaks it
What the four schools of Islamic law hold on i'tikaf, from al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, the Kuwaiti Encyclopedia of Islamic Jurisprudence: 259 views, each with the Encyclopedia's own Arabic words and where they are.
The English is a summary of the Arabic, written with AI and checked against it automatically.
For your own situation, ask a scholar you trust.
The ruling of i'tikaf
In short
- Hanaficonfirmed sunnah / recommended
- Malikirecommended (emphasized), not sunnah
- Other scholarssunnah in Ramadan / recommended outside it
- Shafi'iconfirmed sunnah (more emphatic in last ten days)
- Hanbalisunnah (more emphatic in Ramadan, most emphatic in last ten days)
- All agreesunnah, not obligatory (obligatory only by vow)
- Other scholarsobligatory by vow
- Hanafi
According to the Hanafis, i'tikaf is a confirmed sunnah in the last ten days of Ramadan and recommended outside that time.
Applies when: in the last ten days of Ramadan / outside that time
The Arabic
فقال الحنفية: إنه سنة مؤكدة في العشر الأواخر من رمضان، ومستحب فيما عدا ذلك.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 6
- Maliki
According to the well-known view of the Malikis, i'tikaf is a recommended act that is emphasized, not a sunnah.
The Arabic
وفي المشهور عند المالكية، أنه مندوب مؤكد وليس بسنة.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 6
- Other scholars
Ibn 'Abd al-Barr said that i'tikaf is a sunnah in Ramadan and recommended outside it.
Applies when: in Ramadan / outside Ramadan
The Arabic
وقال ابن عبد البر: إنه سنة في رمضان ومندوب في غيره.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 6
- Shafi'i
According to the Shafi'is, i'tikaf is a confirmed sunnah at all times, and more emphatically so in the last ten days of Ramadan.
Applies when: at all times; more emphatic in the last ten days of Ramadan
The Arabic
وذهب الشافعية إلى أنه سنة مؤكدة، في جميع الأوقات، وفي العشر الأواخر من رمضان آكد
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 6
- Hanbali
According to the Hanbalis, i'tikaf is a sunnah at all times, more emphatic in Ramadan, and most emphatic in the last ten days of Ramadan.
Applies when: at all times; more emphatic in Ramadan; most emphatic in the last ten days
The Arabic
وقال الحنابلة: إنه سنة في كل وقت، وآكده في رمضان، وآكده في العشر الأخير منه.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 6
- All agree
Ibn al-Mundhir reported that all scholars agreed that i'tikaf is a sunnah, not an obligation, unless one makes it obligatory by a vow.
Applies when: unless one makes it obligatory by a vow
The Arabic
قال ابن المنذر: أجمع أهل العلم على أن الاعتكاف سنة، لا يجب على الناس فرضا، إلا أن يوجب المرء على نفسه الاعتكاف نذرا، فيجب عليه.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 6
- Other scholars
I'tikaf becomes obligatory by a vow, based on the Prophet's command to fulfill a vow of obedience.
Applies when: if one vows it
The Arabic
ويلزم الاعتكاف بالنذر، لقول النبي ﷺ: "من نذر أن يطيع الله فليطعه"
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 6
Kinds of i'tikaf
In short
- Majorityobligatory (by vow) and recommended
- Hanafisunnah (voluntary) category added
- Majority
According to the majority, i'tikaf is divided into obligatory and recommended.
The Arabic
ينقسم الاعتكاف إلى واجب، ومندوب عند الجمهور
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 7
- Hanafi
The Hanafis add a third category: the sunnah (voluntary) i'tikaf.
The Arabic
وزاد الحنفية المسنون.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 7
Obligatory i'tikaf
In short
- Majorityobligatory only by vow (immediate or conditional)
- Malikiobligatory by commencing supererogatory i'tikaf
- Hanafiobligatory by commencing supererogatory i'tikaf
- All agreeverbal utterance required, intention in heart insufficient
- Majority
According to the majority, obligatory i'tikaf only becomes obligatory by a vow, whether immediate or conditional.
Applies when: by a vow, immediate or conditional
The Arabic
لا يجب الاعتكاف إلا بالنذر عند الجمهور منجزا أو معلقا
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 8
- Maliki
According to the Malikis, obligatory i'tikaf also becomes obligatory by commencing a supererogatory i'tikaf.
Applies when: by commencing a supererogatory i'tikaf
The Arabic
وبالشروع في الاعتكاف المسنون عند المالكية
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 8
- Hanafi
According to the opposite view among the Hanafis, obligatory i'tikaf also becomes obligatory by commencing a supererogatory i'tikaf.
Applies when: by commencing a supererogatory i'tikaf
The Arabic
ومقابل الظاهر عند الحنفية
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 8
- All agree
All jurists explicitly state that verbal utterance of the intention is required for a vow of i'tikaf, and intention in the heart is not sufficient.
Applies when: for a vow of i'tikaf
The Arabic
صرح الجميع بوجوب التلفظ بالنية، ولا يكفي نية القلب.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 8
Sunnah i'tikaf
- Hanafi
Is there a third category of i'tikaf according to the Hanafis? Yes, they add a 'confirmed sunnah' (sunnah mu'akkadah) which is a communal obligation in the last ten days of Ramadan; if some Muslims perform it, the obligation falls from the rest, and they are not sinful for persistently omitting it without excuse.
Applies when: in the last ten days of Ramadan
The Arabic
زاد الحنفية قسما ثالثا للاعتكاف، وهو ما أطلقوا عليه "سنة مؤكدة" أي سنة كفاية في العشر الأخير من شهر رمضان
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 9
The pillars of i'tikaf
In short
- Majorityfour pillars
- Hanafione pillar: staying in the mosque
- Malikifasting is a pillar
- Majority
What are the pillars of i'tikaf according to the majority? The majority (جمهور) hold that the pillars are four: the person performing i'tikaf, the intention, the place of i'tikaf, and staying in the mosque.
The Arabic
أركان الاعتكاف عند الجمهور أربعة: وهي المعتكف، والنية، والمعتكف فيه، واللبث في المسجد
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 10
- Hanafi
What is the pillar of i'tikaf according to the Hanafis? The Hanafis hold that the only pillar is staying in the mosque; the rest are conditions and parts, not pillars.
The Arabic
ذهب الحنفية إلى أن ركن الاعتكاف هو اللبث في المسجد فقط، والباقي شروط وأطراف لا أركان
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 10
- Maliki
What additional pillar do the Malikis add for i'tikaf? The Malikis add another pillar: fasting.
The Arabic
وزاد المالكية ركنا آخر وهو: الصوم
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 10
Who may make i'tikaf
In short
- All agreevalid
- Other scholarsinvalid
- Other scholarsinvalid
- Other scholarsvalid
- Other scholarsinvalid
- Other scholarsinvalid
- All agree
Is i'tikaf valid from a man, woman, and discerning child? The jurists agree that i'tikaf is valid from a man, a woman, and a discerning child.
The Arabic
اتفق الفقهاء على أنه يصح الاعتكاف من الرجل والمرأة والصبي المميز
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 11
- Other scholars
Is i'tikaf valid from a disbeliever? No, i'tikaf is not valid from a disbeliever because he is not qualified for worship.
Applies when: for obligatory and recommended i'tikaf
The Arabic
اشترطوا لصحة الاعتكاف الواجب والمندوب ما يلي: الإسلام: فلا يصح الاعتكاف من الكافر، لأنه ليس من أهل العبادة
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 11
- Other scholars
Is i'tikaf valid from an insane person, an intoxicated person, an unconscious person, or a non-discerning person? No, it is not valid because they have no intention, and intention is obligatory in i'tikaf.
The Arabic
فلا يصح الاعتكاف من المجنون والسكران والمغمى عليه ومن غير المميز، إذ لا نية لهم، والنية في الاعتكاف واجبة
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 11
- Other scholars
Is i'tikaf valid from a sane, discerning child? Yes, it is valid because he is qualified for worship, just as voluntary fasting is valid from him.
The Arabic
أما الصبي العاقل المميز فيصح منه الاعتكاف، لأنه من أهل العبادة، كما يصح منه صوم التطوع
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 11
- Other scholars
Is i'tikaf valid from a menstruating or postpartum woman? No, it is not valid because they are prohibited from the mosque, and i'tikaf is only valid in a mosque.
The Arabic
النقاء من الحيض والنفاس، فلا يصح الاعتكاف من الحائض والنفساء، لأنهما ممنوعتان عن المسجد، ولا يصح الاعتكاف إلا في مسجد
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 11
- Other scholars
Is i'tikaf valid from a person in a state of major ritual impurity (junub)? No, it is not valid because he is prohibited from staying in the mosque.
The Arabic
الطهارة من الجنب: فلا يصح الاعتكاف من الجنب، لأنه ممنوع من اللبث في المسجد
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 11
I'tikaf for women
- All agree
Is a woman's i'tikaf valid? It is valid by agreement of the jurists, subject to the conditions mentioned earlier.
Applies when: with the conditions mentioned earlier
The Arabic
يصح اعتكاف المرأة باتفاق الفقهاء بالشروط المتقدمة
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 12
- Hanafi
For a married woman, is her husband's permission required for i'tikaf? According to the Hanafis, it is required; i'tikaf is valid without permission but she sins by acting without his consent.
Applies when: married woman, without husband's permission
The Arabic
ويشترط للمتزوجة أن يأذن لها زوجها، لأنها لا ينبغي لها الاعتكاف إلا بإذنه - أي يصح من غير إذنه مع الإثم في الافتيات عليه
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 12
- Hanafi
If a husband has given permission for his wife's obligatory or supererogatory i'tikaf, may he have intercourse with her? According to the Hanafis, he should not have intercourse with her.
Applies when: husband has given permission for wife's i'tikaf, whether obligatory or supererogatory
The Arabic
فإن أذن لها الزوج بالاعتكاف واجبا أو نفلا، فلا ينبغي له أن يطأها
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 12
- Hanafi
If a husband has given permission for i'tikaf and then tries to prevent her, is his prevention valid? According to the Hanafis, his prevention is not valid.
Applies when: husband gave permission then tried to prevent
The Arabic
فإن منعها زوجها بعد إذنه لها لا يصح منعه. هذا قول الحنفية
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 12
- Maliki
May a husband prevent his wife from a vowed i'tikaf after he has given permission? According to the Malikis, he may not prevent her after permission, whether she has entered the i'tikaf or not, unless the vow was absolute and not tied to specific days.
Applies when: husband gave permission for vowed i'tikaf; exception: vow absolute and not tied to specific days
The Arabic
ذهب المالكية إلى أنه لا يحق للزوج أن يمنع زوجته بعد إذنه لها بالاعتكاف المنذور، سواء أدخلت في العبادة أم لم تدخل، إلا إذا كان النذر مطلقا غير مقيد بأيام معينة
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 12
- Maliki
If the vow is absolute and not tied to specific days, may the husband prevent his wife from i'tikaf even after she has entered it? According to the Malikis, he may prevent her even if she has entered the i'tikaf.
Applies when: vow absolute, not tied to specific days, even if she entered the i'tikaf
The Arabic
فإن للزوج حينئذ أن يمنع زوجته من الاعتكاف حتى ولو دخلت في العبادة
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 12
- Maliki
If a woman makes a vow without her husband's permission, whether specified or unspecified, may the husband prevent her? According to the Malikis, he may prevent her, and this applies a fortiori.
Applies when: woman vowed without husband's permission, whether specified or unspecified
The Arabic
ومن باب أولى ما إذا نذرت بغير إذنه معينا أو غير معين
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 12
- Maliki
If a husband gives permission for non-vowed i'tikaf and the wife has entered it, may he interrupt it? According to the Malikis, he may not interrupt it once she has entered.
Applies when: husband gave permission for non-vowed i'tikaf, wife entered it
The Arabic
أما إذا أذن لها في الاعتكاف بدون نذر، فلا يقطعه عليها إن دخلت في الاعتكاف
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 12
- Maliki
If a husband gives permission for non-vowed i'tikaf and the wife has not yet entered it, may he prevent her? According to the Malikis, he may prevent her.
Applies when: husband gave permission for non-vowed i'tikaf, wife has not entered
The Arabic
فإن لم تدخل فيه كان له منعها
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 12
- Hanafi
Is i'tikaf for a woman disliked (makruh tanzihan)? According to the Hanafis, it is disliked, analogous to her attending congregational prayers.
Applies when: for a woman
The Arabic
والاعتكاف للمرأة مكروه تنزيها عند الحنفية، وجعلوه نظير حضورها الجماعات
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 12
- Shafi'i
Is a woman's i'tikaf permissible without her husband's permission? According to the Shafi'is, it is not permissible without her husband's permission, because enjoyment of the wife is the husband's right.
Applies when: without husband's permission
The Arabic
وقال الشافعية: لا يجوز اعتكاف المرأة إلا بإذن زوجها، لأن التمتع بالزوجة من حق الزوج
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 12
- Shafi'i
If a woman is present in the mosque with her husband's permission and intends i'tikaf without depriving her husband of benefit, is it permissible? According to the Shafi'is, it is permissible.
Applies when: woman present in mosque with husband's permission, intends i'tikaf, does not deprive husband of benefit
The Arabic
نعم إن لم تفوت الزوجة على زوجها منفعة، كأن حضرت المسجد بإذنه، فنوت الاعتكاف فإنه يجوز
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 12
- Shafi'i
Is i'tikaf disliked for a beautiful woman of striking appearance? According to the Shafi'is, it is disliked, by analogy with her going out for congregational prayer.
Applies when: beautiful woman of striking appearance
The Arabic
ويكره عندهم اعتكاف المرأة الجميلة ذات الهيئة قياسا على خروجها لصلاة الجماعة
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 12
- Hanbali
May a husband remove his wife from supererogatory i'tikaf, whether it was with his permission or not? According to al-Buhuti al-Hanbali, he may remove her.
Applies when: supererogatory i'tikaf, whether with or without husband's permission
The Arabic
وللزوج إخراج زوجته من الاعتكاف المسنون سواء أكان الاعتكاف بإذنه أم لا، واستدل البهوتي الحنبلي بحديث
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 12
- Hanbali
May a husband remove his wife from a vowed i'tikaf? According to al-Buhuti al-Hanbali, he may remove her, unless he gave permission and she started the i'tikaf, whether the time was specified or consecutive or not.
Applies when: vowed i'tikaf; exception: husband gave permission and she started
The Arabic
وكذا يجوز للزوج إخراجها من الاعتكاف المنذور إلا إذا أذن لها بالاعتكاف وشرعت فيه، سواء أكان زمن الاعتكاف معينا أم كان متتابعا أم لا
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 12
- Shafi'iHanbali
On a wife's i'tikaf and her husband's permission, the Hanbalis rule as the Shafi'is do, except that they do not mention i'tikaf as disliked for a beautiful woman.
Applies when: for a beautiful woman performing i'tikaf
The Arabic
والحنابلة كالشافعية فيما تقدم، إلا في مسألة اعتكاف المرأة الجميلة، فلم يذكروا أنه مكروه
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 12
- Other scholars
It is recommended for a woman performing i'tikaf to conceal herself with a tent or the like.
Applies when: for a woman performing i'tikaf
The Arabic
وإذا اعتكفت المرأة استحب لها أن تستتر بخباء ونحوه
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 12
- Other scholars
It is recommended for a woman to place her tent in a place where men do not pray, because it is more protective for her.
Applies when: for a woman's tent during i'tikaf
The Arabic
وتجعل خباءها في مكان لا يصلي فيه الرجال، لأنه أبعد في التحفظ لها
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 12
- Hanbali
Ahmad ibn Hanbal said: Women may perform i'tikaf in the mosque and tents are pitched for them there.
Applies when: for women performing i'tikaf
The Arabic
نقل أبو داود عن أحمد قوله: "يعتكفن في المسجد، ويضرب لهن فيه بالخيم"
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 12
- Other scholars
There is no harm in men also concealing themselves (with a tent) during i'tikaf, because the Prophet did it and because it hides their deed.
Applies when: for men performing i'tikaf
The Arabic
ولا بأس أن يستتر الرجال أيضا، لفعله ( ولأنه أخفى لعملهم
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 12
- Other scholars
Ibrahim (al-Nakha'i) said: Men should not conceal themselves except in severe cold.
Applies when: for men concealing themselves in i'tikaf except in severe cold
The Arabic
ونقل إبراهيم: لا. إلا لبرد شديد
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 12
The intention for i'tikaf
In short
- HanafiMalikiShafi'iHanbalipillar / condition
- Other scholarsinvalid without intention
- Other scholarsobligatory (distinction in intention)
- HanafiShafi'iHanbalibroken, must renew intention
- HanafiMalikibinding once entered
- HanafiMalikimust make up
- HanafiShafi'iHanbalinot obliged to complete or make up
- HanafiMalikiShafi'iHanbali
Intention is a pillar of i'tikaf according to the Malikis, Shafi'is, and Hanbalis, and a condition according to the Hanafis.
Applies when: for i'tikaf in general
The Arabic
النية ركن للاعتكاف عند المالكية والشافعية والحنابلة، وشرط له عند الحنفية
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 13
- Other scholars
I'tikaf is not valid without intention, whether it is supererogatory or obligatory.
Applies when: for any i'tikaf
The Arabic
فلا يصح اعتكاف بدون نية. سواء أكان الاعتكاف مسنونا أم واجبا
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 13
- Other scholars
One must distinguish between the intention of obligatory and supererogatory i'tikaf so that the obligatory is distinguished from the sunna.
Applies when: when intending i'tikaf
The Arabic
كما يجب التمييز بين نية الفرض والنفل في الاعتكاف، ليتميز الفرض من السنة
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 13
- HanafiShafi'iHanbali
According to the Hanafis (the apparent position of the school), the Shafi'is, and the Hanbalis, if one leaves the mosque during supererogatory i'tikaf, the i'tikaf is broken, and upon returning one must renew the intention for another supererogatory i'tikaf.
Applies when: when leaving the mosque during supererogatory i'tikaf
The Arabic
ذهب الحنفية في الظاهر من المذهب، والشافعية والحنابلة إلى أنه إذا خرج من الاعتكاف المسنون فقد انقطع اعتكافه، وإذا رجع فلا بد من تجديد نية اعتكاف مندوب آخر
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 13
- HanafiMaliki
According to the Malikis and the opposite view among the Hanafis, supererogatory i'tikaf becomes binding once one enters one's place of i'tikaf, whether for a short or long time, because supererogatory acts become binding once begun.
Applies when: for supererogatory i'tikaf after entering the place of i'tikaf
The Arabic
وذهب المالكية، وهو مقابل الظاهر عند الحنفية إلى أن المندوب يلزمه إذا نواه قليلا كان أو كثيرا بدخوله معتكفه
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 13
- HanafiMaliki
According to the Malikis and the opposite Hanafi view, if one enters the place of i'tikaf and then breaks it, one must make it up even if one stipulated not to make it up.
Applies when: when one enters the place of i'tikaf and then breaks it
The Arabic
فإذا دخل ثم قطع لزمه القضاء وإن اشترط عدم القضاء
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 13
- HanafiShafi'iHanbali
According to the apparent position of the Hanafis, the Shafi'is, and the Hanbalis, one is not obliged to complete supererogatory i'tikaf nor to make it up.
Applies when: for supererogatory i'tikaf
The Arabic
والظاهر من مذهب الحنفية والشافعية والحنابلة أنه لا يلزمه الإتمام ولا قضاء عليه
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 13
Where a man makes i'tikaf
- All agree
The jurists are unanimous that the i'tikaf of a man, or of a person of unclear sex (khuntha), is valid only in a mosque.
Applies when: for a man and a khuntha (hermaphrodite)
The Arabic
أجمع الفقهاء على أنه لا يصح اعتكاف الرجل والخنثى إلا في مسجد
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 14
- All agree
Are the three mosques (Makkah, Madinah, al-Aqsa) better than others for i'tikaf? Agreed: they are better, with the Sacred Mosque being best, then the Prophet's Mosque, then al-Aqsa.
The Arabic
واتفقوا على أن المساجد الثلاثة أفضل من غيرها، والمسجد الحرام أفضل، ثم المسجد النبوي، ثم المسجد الأقصى
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 14
- All agree
Is i'tikaf valid in a congregational mosque (al-masjid al-jami')? Agreed: it is valid, and it is preferable over other mosques after the three mosques.
The Arabic
واتفقوا على أن المسجد الجامع يصح فيه الاعتكاف، وهو أولى من غيره بعد المساجد الثلاثة
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 14
- Shafi'i
If someone vows i'tikaf for a period that includes a Friday prayer, it must be done in a mosque where the Friday prayer is held, so that he need not leave for it; for the Shafi'is, unless he stipulated beforehand that he would go out for it.
Applies when: if one vows a period that coincides with Friday prayer, except when the Shafi'is stipulate permission to go out for it
The Arabic
ويجب الاعتكاف فيه إذا نذر الاعتكاف مدة تصادفه فيها صلاة الجمعة، لئلا يحتاج إلى الخروج وقت صلاة الجمعة، إلا إذا اشترط الخروج لها عند الشافعية
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 14
- HanafiHanbali
Is i'tikaf valid only in a mosque where congregational prayer is held? The Hanafis and Hanbalis hold that it is not valid except in a mosque of congregation (masjid jama'ah).
The Arabic
فذهب الحنفية والحنابلة إلى أنه لا يصح الاعتكاف إلا في مسجد جماعة
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 14
- Hanafi
Is i'tikaf valid only in a mosque where the five daily prayers are performed? Abu Hanifa holds that it is not valid except in a mosque where the five prayers are held, because i'tikaf is an act of waiting for prayer.
The Arabic
وعن أبي حنيفة أنه لا يصح الاعتكاف إلا في مسجد تقام فيه الصلوات الخمس
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 14
- Other scholars
Is i'tikaf valid in any mosque? Abu Yusuf and Muhammad (al-Shaybani) hold that it is valid in any mosque, and al-Saruji authenticated this.
The Arabic
وقال أبو يوسف ومحمد: يصح في كل مسجد وصححه السروجي
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 14
- Other scholars
Does the ruling differ for obligatory and supererogatory i'tikaf? Abu Yusuf distinguishes: for obligatory i'tikaf he requires a congregational mosque, while supererogatory i'tikaf is permissible in any mosque.
The Arabic
وعن أبي يوسف أنه فرق بين الاعتكاف الواجب والمسنون، فاشترط للاعتكاف الواجب مسجد الجماعة، وأما النفل فيجوز في أي مسجد كان
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 14
- Hanafi
What do the Hanafis mean by 'mosque of congregation'? They mean a mosque that has an imam and a muezzin, whether the five prayers are performed there or not.
The Arabic
ويعني الحنفية بمسجد الجماعة ما له إمام ومؤذن، أديت فيه الصلوات الخمس أو لا
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 14
- Hanbali
Is i'tikaf in a mosque valid only if congregational prayer is held there? The Hanbalis require the congregation to be held during the time of the i'tikaf; it does not matter if it is not held at other times. This does not apply to a woman, someone with an excuse, a boy, or someone in a village where no one else prays.
Applies when: except for women, the excused, a boy, and someone in a village where no one else prays, because the prohibition of leaving obligatory congregation does not apply to them
The Arabic
واشترط الحنابلة لصحة الاعتكاف في المسجد أن تقام الجماعة في زمن الاعتكاف الذي هو فيه، ولا يضر عدم إقامتها في الوقت الذي لا يعتكف فيه، وخرج من ذلك المرأة والمعذور والصبي ومن هو في قرية لا يصلي فيها غيره
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 14
- MalikiShafi'i
Is i'tikaf valid in any mosque? The Malikis and Shafi'is hold that it is valid in any mosque.
The Arabic
والمذهب عند المالكية والشافعية أنه يصح الاعتكاف في أي مسجد كان
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 14
Where a woman makes i'tikaf
In short
- MajorityShafi'ivalid only in a mosque
- Shafi'i (one view)valid
- Hanafipermissible
- Hanafipermissible with slight dislike
- Hanafinot permissible
- Hanafinot permissible
- Hanafinot permissible to leave
- MajorityShafi'i
Is a woman's i'tikaf valid only in a mosque? The majority and al-Shafi'i in the new opinion hold that a woman's i'tikaf is not valid except in a mosque, like a man.
The Arabic
فذهب الجمهور والشافعي في المذهب الجديد إلى أنها كالرجل لا يصح اعتكافها إلا في المسجد
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 15
- Shafi'i (one view)
Is a woman's i'tikaf valid in the mosque of her house? According to the old opinion of al-Shafi'i, a woman's i'tikaf is valid in the mosque of her house because it is her place of prayer.
Applies when: in the mosque of her house
The Arabic
وفي المذهب القديم للشافعي: أنه يصح اعتكاف المرأة في مسجد بيتها، لأنه مكان صلاتها
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 15
- Hanafi
Is a woman's i'tikaf permissible in the mosque of her house? The Hanafis hold that a woman's i'tikaf is permissible in the mosque of her house.
Applies when: in the mosque of her house
The Arabic
وذهب الحنفية إلى جواز اعتكاف المرأة في مسجد بيتها
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 15
- Hanafi
Is a woman's i'tikaf permissible in the congregational mosque? According to the Hanafis, if a woman performs i'tikaf in the congregational mosque it is permissible with slight dislike, and her house is better than the mosque of her neighborhood, and the mosque of her neighborhood is better for her than the grand mosque.
Applies when: in the congregational mosque
The Arabic
ولو اعتكفت في مسجد الجماعة جاز مع الكراهة التنزيهية، والبيت أفضل من مسجد حيها، ومسجد الحي أفضل لها من المسجد الأعظم
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 15
- Hanafi
May a woman perform i'tikaf in a place other than her prayer spot in her house? According to the Hanafis, a woman may not perform i'tikaf in any place other than her prayer spot in her house.
Applies when: in a place other than her prayer spot in her house
The Arabic
وليس للمرأة أن تعتكف في غير موضع صلاتها من بيتها
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 15
- Hanafi
If a woman has no designated prayer place in her house, is i'tikaf permissible for her in her house? According to the Hanafis, if she has no place in the house designated for prayer, i'tikaf in her house is not permissible.
Applies when: if she has no place in the house designated for prayer
The Arabic
وإن لم يكن لها في البيت مكان متخذ للصلاة لا يجوز لها الاعتكاف في بيتها
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 15
- Hanafi
If a woman has undertaken a obligatory i'tikaf in her house, may she leave that house? According to the Hanafis, she may not leave the house in which she has performed an obligatory i'tikaf.
Applies when: if she has undertaken an obligatory i'tikaf in her house
The Arabic
وليس لها أن تخرج من بيتها الذي اعتكفت فيه اعتكافا واجبا عليها
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 15
Staying in the mosque
In short
- HanafiHanbalivalid with any duration that qualifies as staying
- Hanbalirecommended (mustahabb) to be at least a day and a night
- Maliki (one view)minimum is a day and a night
- Malikiminimum is a day or more
- Shafi'ivalid if it qualifies as staying, even briefly
- Shafi'irecommended (mandub) to be a day
- HanafiHanbali
What is the minimum duration of staying in the mosque for a supererogatory (non-obligatory) i'tikaf? According to the Hanafis (the view of Muhammad and the apparent narration from Abu Hanifah, which is the basis for fatwa) and the Hanbalis (the madhhab), it is the shortest period that can be called i'tikaf and staying, even if it is a moment.
Applies when: for supererogatory or absolutely vowed i'tikaf
The Arabic
ذهب الحنفية إلى أن أقله ساعة من ليل أو نهار عند محمد، وهو ظاهر الرواية عن أبي حنيفة ... وهو المذهب عند الحنابلة. قال في الإنصاف: أقله إذا كان تطوعا أو نذرا مطلقا ما يسمى به معتكفا لابثا. قال في الفروع: ظاهره ولو لحظة
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 16
- Hanbali
What is the recommended minimum duration for i'tikaf according to the Hanbalis? It is recommended not to be less than a day and a night, to avoid the disagreement of those who say the minimum is that.
Applies when: for supererogatory i'tikaf
The Arabic
والمستحب عندهم ألا ينقص الاعتكاف عن يوم وليلة، خروجا من خلاف من يقول: أقله ذلك.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 16
- Maliki (one view)
What is the minimum stay in the mosque for i'tikaf according to some Malikis? It is a day and a night, excluding the time he must leave for necessary bodily functions.
The Arabic
فذهب بعضهم إلى أنه يوم وليلة، سوى وقت خروجه لما يتعين عليه الخروج لأجله، من البول والغائط والوضوء وغسل الجنابة
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 16
- Maliki
What is the minimum stay in the mosque for i'tikaf according to other Malikis? It is a day or more, if he enters i'tikaf at dawn, considering that the beginning of the day is dawn.
Applies when: if he enters i'tikaf at dawn
The Arabic
وذهب آخرون إلى أن أقله يوم فما فوقه إذا كان دخوله في الاعتكاف مع الفجر، باعتبار أن أول اليوم الفجر.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 16
- Shafi'i
What is the minimum stay in the mosque for i'tikaf according to the Shafi'is? It is not defined by a specific time, but must be a duration that can be called 'ukuf (staying) and iqamah (remaining), even without stillness, as long as it is longer than the time of tranquility (tuma'ninah) in bowing and the like; merely passing through without staying is insufficient.
The Arabic
وعند الشافعية لا يقدر اللبث بزمان، بل اشترطوا في اللبث أن يكون قدرا يسمى عكوفا وإقامة، ولو بلا سكون بحيث يكون زمنه فوق زمن الطمأنينة في الركوع ونحوه، فيكفي التردد فيه لا المرور بلا لبث.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 16
- Shafi'i
What is recommended for the duration of i'tikaf according to the Shafi'is? It is recommended (mandub) that it be a day, because it is not reported that the Prophet ﷺ or any of the Companions performed i'tikaf for less than a day.
The Arabic
ويندب عندهم أن يكون يوما، لأنه لم يرد أن النبي ﷺ اعتكف أقل من يوم ولا أحد من الصحابة.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 16
Fasting during i'tikaf
In short
- MajorityHanafi (one view)MalikiShafi'i (one view)invalid without fasting
- Shafi'iHanbalinot required
- Shafi'iHanbalibetter (preferred)
- Shafi'iHanbalidoes not invalidate i'tikaf
- Hanafinot a condition
- MajorityHanafi (one view)MalikiShafi'i (one view)
Is fasting obligatory for i'tikaf? The first position holds that i'tikaf is not valid without fasting, and this is held by Abu Hanifa in a narration from al-Hasan, some Hanafi scholars, the Malikis, Ibn 'Umar, Ibn 'Abbas, 'A'ishah, 'Urwah ibn al-Zubayr, al-Zuhri, al-Awza'i, al-Thawri, and an old view of al-Shafi'i, and it is the view of the majority of scholars.
Applies when: for i'tikaf
The Arabic
لا يصح الاعتكاف إلا بصوم، وبه قال أبو حنيفة في رواية الحسن عنه، ومن مشايخ الحنفية من اعتمد هذه الرواية، وهو مذهب المالكية، وبه قال ابن عمر وابن عباس وعائشة وعروة بن الزبير والزهري والأوزاعي والثوري، وهو قول قديم محكي عن الشافعي، قالوا: لا يصح الاعتكاف إلا بصوم. قال القاضي عياض: وهو قول جمهور العلماء.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 17
- Shafi'iHanbali
Is fasting obligatory for i'tikaf? The second position holds that fasting is not a condition for i'tikaf at all, whether obligatory or supererogatory, and this is held by the Shafi'is, Hanbalis, al-Hasan al-Basri, Abu Thawr, Dawud, Ibn al-Mundhir, and it is narrated from 'Ali and Ibn Mas'ud.
Applies when: for i'tikaf, whether obligatory or supererogatory
The Arabic
ذهب الشافعية والحنابلة إلى أنه لا يشترط الصوم للاعتكاف مطلقا، سواء أكان واجبا أم مندوبا، فالصوم ليس شرطا للاعتكاف عندهم ولا ركنا فيه. وبه قال الحسن البصري وأبو ثور وداود وابن المنذر، وهو مروي عن علي وابن مسعود.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 17
- Shafi'iHanbali
Is fasting recommended in i'tikaf? The Shafi'is and Hanbalis state that i'tikaf with fasting is better than i'tikaf without it.
Applies when: for i'tikaf
The Arabic
إلا أنهم صرحوا بأن الاعتكاف مع الصوم أفضل من الاعتكاف بدونه
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 17
- Shafi'iHanbali
Does breaking the fast intentionally without excuse invalidate i'tikaf? According to the Shafi'is and Hanbalis, if someone observing i'tikaf fasts and then intentionally breaks the fast without excuse, his i'tikaf is not invalidated and he incurs no penalty.
Applies when: if someone in i'tikaf fasts and then intentionally breaks the fast without excuse
The Arabic
فلو اعتكف صائما ثم أفطر عامدا بغير عذر لا يبطل اعتكافه، ولا شيء عليه، لصحة اعتكافه بغير صوم
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 17
- Hanafi
Is fasting a condition for supererogatory i'tikaf? According to the apparent narration from Abu Hanifa and the view of Abu Yusuf and Muhammad, fasting is not a condition for supererogatory i'tikaf.
Applies when: for supererogatory i'tikaf
The Arabic
فإنهم قالوا: إن الصوم ليس بشرط في الاعتكاف المندوب، كما في ظاهر الرواية عن أبي حنيفة، وهو قول أبي يوسف ومحمد.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 17
Intending to fast for a vowed i'tikaf
In short
- Hanafivalid only with obligatory fast
- Hanafibinding; make-up required with consecutive month
- Hanafiinvalid
- Other scholarsbinding if said before midday; make-up required
- Malikivalid with any fast; invalid without fasting
- Hanafi
According to the Hanafis, obligatory iʿtikāf is only valid with an obligatory fast, and is not valid with a voluntary fast.
Applies when: obligatory iʿtikāf
The Arabic
ذهب الحنفية إلى أن الاعتكاف الواجب لا يصح إلا بصوم واجب، ولا يصح مع صوم التطوع
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 18
- Hanafi
According to the Hanafis, if someone vows to observe iʿtikāf during Ramadan, it is binding and the Ramadan fast suffices for the fast of iʿtikāf; if he does not observe it, he must make it up with a consecutive month of fasting.
Applies when: vowing iʿtikāf in Ramadan and failing to observe it
The Arabic
فلو نذر اعتكاف شهر رمضان لزمه وأجزأه صوم رمضان عن صوم الاعتكاف، فإن لم يعتكفه قضى شهرا متتابعا غيره
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 18
- Hanafi
According to the Hanafis, if someone fasts voluntarily and then vows to observe iʿtikāf on that day, the iʿtikāf is not valid because the day is not entirely covered by iʿtikāf and not entirely covered by an obligatory fast.
Applies when: voluntary fast followed by vowing iʿtikāf on that same day
The Arabic
فلو صام تطوعا، ثم نذر اعتكاف ذلك اليوم لم يصح الاعتكاف، لعدم استيعاب الاعتكاف للنهار
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 18
- Other scholars
According to Abū Yūsuf, the minimum (for the fast accompanying a vowed iʿtikāf) is most of the day; if the vow is made before midday it becomes binding, and if he does not observe it he must make it up.
Applies when: vowing iʿtikāf on a day, said before half the day
The Arabic
وعند أبي يوسف أقله أكثر النهار، فإن كان قاله قبل نصف النهار لزمه، فإن لم يعتكفه قضاه
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 18
- Maliki
According to the Malikis, both obligatory and recommended iʿtikāf are valid with any kind of fast—whether tied to a time like Ramadan, or a cause like expiation or vow, or absolute like voluntary fasting—and iʿtikāf is not valid from a person who is not fasting, even for an excuse.
Applies when: all types of iʿtikāf (obligatory and recommended)
The Arabic
وذهب المالكية إلى أن الاعتكاف بقسميه الواجب والمسنون يصح بأي صوم كان ... فلا يصح الاعتكاف من مفطر، ولو لعذر
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 18
Vowing i'tikaf
- Other scholars
If someone vows iʿtikāf, it becomes binding to perform it, whether the vow is immediate or conditional.
Applies when: vowing iʿtikāf (immediate or conditional)
The Arabic
إذا نذر الاعتكاف لزمه أداؤه، سواء أكان منجزا أم معلقا
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 19
A vow of consecutive days
- All agree
If someone vows ten consecutive days or a consecutive month of iʿtikāf, it is binding to observe it consecutively according to all of them; if he breaks it, the consecutiveness is lost and must be restarted.
Applies when: vowing consecutive iʿtikāf (e.g., ten days or a month)
The Arabic
فإنه يلزمه متتابعا في قولهم جميعا فلو أفسده وجب استثناؤه بفوات التتابع
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 20
An open vow, and a set period
- Hanafi
If one vows an absolute (unconditional) iʿtikāf of days that are not specified to be consecutive, is it required to perform them consecutively according to the Ḥanafī school? Yes, it is required.
Applies when: vowing an absolute iʿtikāf of days not specified as consecutive
The Arabic
فإن نوى أياما غير متتابعة، فإنها تلزمه متتابعة عند الحنفية
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 21
- Maliki
If one vows an absolute iʿtikāf of days not specified as consecutive, is it required to perform them consecutively according to the Mālikī school? No, unless he vowed them separately, in which case they must be performed separately.
Applies when: vowing an absolute iʿtikāf of days not specified as consecutive
The Arabic
وكذلك عند المالكية إلا إذا نذرها متفرقة فتجب متفرقة، ولا يلزمه التتابع
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 21
- Shafi'i
If one vows an absolute (unconditional) iʿtikāf, is consecutive performance required according to the Shāfiʿī school? No, it may be performed separately.
Applies when: vowing an absolute iʿtikāf
The Arabic
أما الشافعية فإن النذر المطلق عندهم لا يلزم فيه التتابع، فيجوز أداؤه مفرقا
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 21
- Shafi'i
If one leaves his iʿtikāf during the days of an absolute vow without intending to return, does he need to renew the intention? Yes, according to the Shāfiʿī school.
Applies when: leaving iʿtikāf during an absolute vow without intending to return
The Arabic
لو خرج من معتكفه خلال أيام النذر المطلق، إن لم يعزم على العود احتاج إلى استئناف نية الاعتكاف
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 21
- Shafi'i
If one leaves his iʿtikāf during the days of an absolute vow intending to return, does the intention to return suffice as a new intention? Yes, according to the correct view in the Shāfiʿī school.
Applies when: leaving iʿtikāf during an absolute vow intending to return
The Arabic
فإن عزم على العود كانت هذه العزيمة قائمة مقام النية، وهو الصواب كما في المجموع
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 21
- HanafiMaliki
If one vows iʿtikāf for a specified period, is consecutive performance required according to the Ḥanafī and Mālikī schools? Yes.
Applies when: vowing iʿtikāf for a specified period
The Arabic
أما إذا نوى مدة معينة فكذلك عند الحنفية والمالكية
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 21
- Shafi'i
If one vows iʿtikāf for a specified period, is consecutive performance required according to the Shāfiʿī school? No, but if he leaves for other than relieving himself he needs to renew the intention.
Applies when: vowing iʿtikāf for a specified period
The Arabic
وعند الشافعية لا يلزمه التتابع، لكن إن خرج لغير قضاء الحاجة احتاج إلى استئناف النية
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 21
- Hanbali
If one vows iʿtikāf for a specific month, is consecutive performance required according to the Ḥanbalī school? Yes.
Applies when: vowing iʿtikāf for a specific month
The Arabic
وعند الحنابلة أن تعيين مدة للاعتكاف كشهر بعينه يلزمه التتابع
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 21
- Hanbali
If one vows an absolute month of iʿtikāf, is it required according to the Ḥanbalī school? Yes, and there are two opinions on whether it must be consecutive.
Applies when: vowing an absolute month of iʿtikāf
The Arabic
وإن نذر شهرا مطلقا لزمه، ولهم قولان في التتابع وعدمه
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 21
- Hanbali (one view)
If someone vows a month of i'tikaf without naming which month, do its days have to be consecutive? In one Hanbali view, yes.
Applies when: vowing an absolute month of iʿtikāf
The Arabic
أحدهما كالحنفية
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 21
- Hanbali (one view)
If someone vows a month of i'tikaf without naming which month, do its days have to be consecutive? In the other Hanbali view they do not; al-Ajurri chose this view and Ibn Shihab and others called it correct.
Applies when: vowing an absolute month of iʿtikāf
The Arabic
والثاني كالشافعية اختارها الآجري وصححها ابن شهاب وغيره
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 21
- Other scholars
Is consecutive performance required in an absolute month of iʿtikāf according to the author of Kashshāf al-Qināʿ? Yes.
Applies when: vowing an absolute month of iʿtikāf
The Arabic
ونص صاحب كشاف القناع على وجوب التتابع
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 21
- Shafi'i
Is consecutive performance better than non-consecutive in an absolute vow of iʿtikāf according to the Shāfiʿī school? Yes.
Applies when: absolute vow of iʿtikāf
The Arabic
والتتابع عند الشافعية في النذر المطلق أفضل من التفريق
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 21
- Shafi'iHanbali
If one vows a single day of iʿtikāf, is it permissible to perform it in separate parts according to the Shāfiʿī and Ḥanbalī schools? No.
Applies when: vowing a single day of iʿtikāf
The Arabic
وعند الشافعية والحنابلة: لو نذر يوما لم يجز فيه التفريق
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 21
- Shafi'iHanbali
If one vows a day of iʿtikāf starting from the middle of the day, does he need to observe iʿtikāf from that time to the same time the next day? Yes, according to the Shāfiʿī and Ḥanbalī schools.
Applies when: vowing a day of iʿtikāf from the middle of the day
The Arabic
ولو نذر يوما من وسط النهار لزمه الاعتكاف من ذلك الوقت إلى مثله ليتحقق مضي يوم من ذلك الوقت
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 21
- Shafi'iHanbali
If one vows iʿtikāf of the daytime only, is the night included? No, according to the Shāfiʿī and Ḥanbalī schools.
Applies when: vowing iʿtikāf of the daytime only
The Arabic
وأما الليل فلا يلزمه بنذر اعتكاف النهار لأنه ليس من اليوم عندهما
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 21
- Shafi'i
Can the night be included with the day by intention in a vow of daytime iʿtikāf according to the Shāfiʿī school? Yes.
Applies when: vowing iʿtikāf of the daytime with intention to include night
The Arabic
وقال الشافعية: يدخل الليل مع اليوم بالنية
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 21
- All agreeShafi'i
If one vows iʿtikāf of a specific month without qualification, does it include both night and day? Yes, and if the month is incomplete it suffices, without disagreement among the Shāfiʿīs.
Applies when: vowing iʿtikāf of a specific month without qualification
The Arabic
وإذا نذر اعتكاف شهر بعينه وأطلق لزمه ليلا ونهارا، تاما كان الشهر أو ناقصا ويجزئه الناقص بلا خلاف عند الشافعية
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 21
When to enter an obligatory i'tikaf
In short
- HanafiShafi'iHanbalienters before dawn
- Shafi'iHanbalienters before sunset
- HanafiMalikinot valid
- Malikiobligatory with its day
- HanafiShafi'iHanbali
When does obligatory i'tikaf begin? The Hanafis, Shafi'is, and Hanbalis hold that the person enters his place of i'tikaf if he intends a day before dawn.
Applies when: if he intends a day before dawn
The Arabic
ذهب الحنفية والشافعية والحنابلة إلى أنه يدخل معتكفه إذا نوى يوما قبل الفجر
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 22
- Shafi'iHanbali
The Shafi'is and Hanbalis hold that if he intends a night before sunset, he enters his place of i'tikaf.
Applies when: if he intends a night before sunset
The Arabic
وعند الشافعية والحنابلة إذا نوى ليلا قبل غروب الشمس
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 22
- HanafiMaliki
The Hanafis and Malikis hold that vowing a night alone is not valid because there is no fasting in it.
Applies when: vowing a night alone
The Arabic
لأن الحنفية والمالكية لا يصح عندهم نذر الليل وحده، لأنه لا صيام فيه
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 22
- Maliki
According to the Malikis, if someone vows a night, it becomes obligatory for him together with its day, because the minimum is a day and a night.
Applies when: if someone vows a night
The Arabic
لكن لو نذر ليلة أي ليلة كانت عند المالكية لزمته مع نهارها، لأن أقله يوم وليلة
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 22
Vowing to fast with a vowed i'tikaf
In short
- HanafiMalikinot valid without fasting
- Shafi'iHanbalinot obligatory to combine
- Shafi'iHanbaliboth obligatory
- Shafi'iHanbaliboth obligatory
- HanafiMaliki
The Hanafis and Malikis hold that obligatory and supererogatory i'tikaf are not valid without fasting, and they differed regarding the recommended (mandub).
Applies when: obligatory and supererogatory i'tikaf
The Arabic
سبق أن الحنفية والمالكية لا يصح عندهم الاعتكاف الواجب والمسنون إلا بصوم واختلفوا في المندوب
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 23
- Shafi'iHanbali
The Shafi'is and Hanbalis agreed that if someone vows fasting and i'tikaf, combining both is not obligatory for him.
Applies when: if someone vows fasting and i'tikaf
The Arabic
اتفقوا على أنه إذا نذر صوما واعتكافا لا يلزمه الجمع بينهما
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 23
- Shafi'iHanbali
The Shafi'is and Hanbalis agreed that if someone vows to perform i'tikaf while fasting, both are obligatory for him.
Applies when: if someone vows to perform i'tikaf while fasting
The Arabic
اتفقوا على أنه إذا نذر أن يعتكف صائما لزماه
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 23
- Shafi'iHanbali
The correct view among the Shafi'is and Hanbalis is that if someone vows to fast while in i'tikaf, both are obligatory for him.
Applies when: if someone vows to fast while in i'tikaf
The Arabic
فالصحيح عند الشافعية والحنابلة أنهما يلزمانه
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 23
Vowing to pray during i'tikaf
In short
- Shafi'iprayer not obligatory
- Hanbaliobligatory to combine
- Shafi'i
The Shafi'is hold that if someone vows to perform i'tikaf while praying, prayer is not obligatory for him.
Applies when: if someone vows to perform i'tikaf while praying
The Arabic
ذهب الشافعية إلى أن من نذر أن يعتكف مصليا فالصلاة لا تلزمه
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 24
- Hanbali
According to the Hanbalis, if someone vows to perform i'tikaf while praying, combining both is obligatory for him.
Applies when: if someone vows to perform i'tikaf while praying
The Arabic
وعند الحنابلة يلزمه الجمع بينهما
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 24
Vowing i'tikaf in a particular mosque
In short
- All agreebinding, must be fulfilled, does not suffice in others
- Other scholarsdoes not suffice
- Other scholarsdoes not suffice
- Other scholarspermissible (jāz)
- Other scholarspermissible (jāz)
- MalikiShafi'iHanbalinot binding, may perform elsewhere
- Hanbaligiven a choice
- Other scholarspermitted (by some), not permitted (by Ibn 'Aqil and Ibn Taymiyya)
- Hanbaligiven a choice
- Other scholarsfulfillment is better (أفضل, أظهر)
- All agree
The jurists agree that if someone vows i'tikaf in one of the three mosques (the Sacred Mosque, the Prophet's Mosque or al-Aqsa), the vow binds him and he must fulfil it there; i'tikaf in any other mosque does not count for it.
Applies when: when the vow is for one of the three mosques
The Arabic
اتفق الفقهاء على أنه إذا نذر الاعتكاف في أحد المساجد الثلاثة - المسجد الحرام، ومسجد النبي (، والمسجد الأقصى - لزمه النذر وعليه الوفاء، ولا يجزئه الاعتكاف في غيرها من المساجد
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 25
- Other scholars
If someone vows i'tikaf in the Sacred Mosque, i'tikaf in the Prophet's Mosque or al-Aqsa Mosque does not suffice.
Applies when: when the vow specifies the Sacred Mosque
The Arabic
فإن عين بنذره المسجد الحرام لا يجزئه في مسجد النبي ﷺ ولا المسجد الأقصى
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 25
- Other scholars
If someone vows i'tikaf in the Prophet's Mosque, i'tikaf in al-Aqsa Mosque does not suffice.
Applies when: when the vow specifies the Prophet's Mosque
The Arabic
وإن عين مسجد النبي ﷺ لا يجزئه المسجد الأقصى
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 25
- Other scholars
If someone vows i'tikaf in al-Aqsa Mosque, i'tikaf in the Prophet's Mosque or the Sacred Mosque is permissible.
Applies when: when the vow specifies al-Aqsa Mosque
The Arabic
فإن عين المسجد الأقصى جاز في مسجد النبي (، وفي المسجد الحرام
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 25
- Other scholars
If someone vows i'tikaf in the Prophet's Mosque, i'tikaf in the Sacred Mosque is permissible.
Applies when: when the vow specifies the Prophet's Mosque
The Arabic
وإن عين مسجد النبي جاز في المسجد الحرام
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 25
- MalikiShafi'iHanbali
If someone vows i'tikaf in a mosque other than the three, according to the Malikis, the preferred view of the Shafi'is, and the correct view of the Hanbalis, the vow is not binding and he may perform it elsewhere.
Applies when: when the vow is for a mosque other than the three
The Arabic
وأما إذا نذر الاعتكاف في غير المساجد الثلاثة فهل يلزم ؟ ذهب المالكية وهو المذهب عند الشافعية والصحيح عند الحنابلة إلى أنه لا يلزمه، وله فعله في غيره
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 25
- Hanbali
If someone vows i'tikaf in a particular mosque, other than the three great mosques, that can only be reached by a journey, the Hanbalis hold that he may choose whether to go there or not, according to al-Qadi Abu Ya'la and others.
Applies when: when the mosque requires traveling
The Arabic
وأما إذا كان المسجد يحتاج إلى شد الرحال إليه فيخير عند الحنابلة، وهو قول للمالكية بين الذهاب وعدمه عند القاضي أبي يعلى وغيره
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 25
- Other scholars
Some (scholars) chose permissibility for a short journey (to such a mosque), while Ibn 'Aqil and Shaykh Taqi al-Din Ibn Taymiyya did not permit it.
Applies when: for a short journey to a mosque vowed for i'tikaf
The Arabic
واختار بعضهم الإباحة في السفر القصير، ولم يجوزه ابن عقيل والشيخ تقي الدين ابن تيمية
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 25
- Hanbali
According to the correct view of the Hanbali school, if the mosque does not require traveling, the person is given a choice between going or not.
Applies when: when the mosque does not require traveling
The Arabic
وكذلك يخير على الصحيح من المذهب إن كان لا يحتاج إلى شد رحل بين الذهاب وغيره
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 25
- Other scholars
In al-Wadih, fulfilling the vow (by going to the specified mosque) is better; in al-Furu', this is said to be more apparent.
Applies when: when the mosque does not require traveling
The Arabic
لكن قال في الواضح: الوفاء أفضل، قال في الفروع: وهذا أظهر
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 25
Setting conditions in i'tikaf
- Majority
Is it permissible to stipulate conditions in a obligatory retreat? The majority (جمهور) permit stipulating conditions and consider them valid in obligatory retreat.
Applies when: in obligatory retreat (الاعتكاف الواجب)
The Arabic
ذهب الجمهور إلى جواز الشرط وصحته في الاعتكاف الواجب.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 26
- MalikiShafi'i
Do the Malikis and the opposite view among the Shafi'is nullify stipulations in retreat? The Malikis and the view opposite to the apparent (الأظهر) among the Shafi'is hold that the stipulation is void.
The Arabic
وذهب المالكية وهو مقابل الأظهر عند الشافعية: إلى إلغاء الشرط.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 26
- Hanafi
According to the Hanafis, if one stipulates at the time of the vow to leave for visiting the sick, praying over a funeral, or attending a scholarly gathering, is that permissible? The Hanafis said it is permissible.
Applies when: when stipulating at the time of the vow (وقت النذر) to leave for visiting the sick, praying over a funeral, or attending a scholarly gathering
The Arabic
فقال الحنفية: لو اشترط وقت النذر أن يخرج لعيادة مريض وصلاة جنازة وحضور مجلس علم جاز ذلك.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 26
- Maliki
According to the relied-upon Maliki view, if the person in retreat stipulates for himself the dropping of the make-up (qada') in case an excuse or invalidator occurs, does that benefit him? The Malikis said in the relied-upon view: the stipulation does not benefit him, his stipulation is void, he must make up if its cause occurs, and his retreat is valid.
Applies when: if the person in retreat stipulates for himself the dropping of the make-up (سقوط القضاء) on the assumption that an excuse or invalidator occurs
The Arabic
أما المالكية فقد قالوا في المعتمد: لو اشترط المعتكف لنفسه سقوط القضاء عنه - على فرض حصول عذر أو مبطل - لا ينفعه اشتراط سقوط القضاء، وشرطه لغو، ويجب عليه القضاء إن حصل موجبه، واعتكافه صحيح.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 26
- Maliki (one view)
According to another Maliki view, if the person in retreat stipulates the dropping of make-up, does the retreat contract? They have another view that it does not contract.
Applies when: if the person in retreat stipulates the dropping of make-up
The Arabic
ولهم قول آخر بأنه لا ينعقد
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 26
- Maliki (one view)
According to a third Maliki view, is there a distinction between stipulations before entering retreat and after entering? They have a third view of detail: if stipulations are before entering the retreat, the retreat does not contract; if after entering, the stipulation is void.
Applies when: distinction between stipulations before entering retreat (قبل الدخول في الاعتكاف) and after entering (بعد الدخول)
The Arabic
وقول ثالث بالتفصيل بين الاشتراطات قبل الدخول في الاعتكاف فلا ينعقد الاعتكاف، أو بعد الدخول فيلغو الشرط.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 26
- Shafi'iHanbali
According to the Hanbalis and the apparent view among the Shafi'is, does the retreat become binding according to what one has committed? The Hanbalis and the apparent view among the Shafi'is said: the retreat becomes binding by undertaking it, so it is obligatory according to what one has committed.
The Arabic
وقال الحنابلة وهو الأظهر عند الشافعية: إن الاعتكاف لزم بالتزامه فيجب بحسب ما التزمه.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 26
- Hanbali
According to the Hanbalis, if the person in retreat stipulates leaving for a permissible, intended, non-contradictory purpose, is the stipulation valid? The Hanbalis said: if he stipulates leaving for a permissible, intended purpose that does not contradict retreat, the stipulation is valid.
Applies when: if the person in retreat stipulates leaving for a permissible, intended purpose (عارض مباح مقصود) that does not contradict retreat
The Arabic
فإذا اشترط المعتكف الخروج لعارض مباح مقصود غير مناف للاعتكاف صح الشرط.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 26
- Hanbali
According to the Hanbalis, if the person in retreat stipulates leaving for a specific purpose like visiting the sick, may he leave for that purpose only? The Hanbalis said: if he stipulates it for a specific purpose, like visiting the sick, he leaves for it and not for other purposes, even if others are more important.
Applies when: if he stipulates leaving for a specific purpose (خاص من الأغراض), e.g. visiting the sick
The Arabic
فإن اشترطه لخاص من الأغراض، كعيادة المرضى خرج له دون غيره، وإن كان غيره أهم منه.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 26
- Hanbali
According to the Hanbalis, if the person in retreat stipulates leaving for a general matter like an arising occupation, may he leave for every important religious or permissible worldly matter? The Hanbalis said: if he stipulates it for a general matter like an arising occupation, he leaves for every important religious matter like Friday and congregation, or permissible worldly matter like collecting a debt, but he may not leave for something forbidden.
Applies when: if he stipulates leaving for a general matter (أمر عام) like an arising occupation (شغل يعرض له)
The Arabic
وإن اشترطه لأمر عام كشغل يعرض له خرج لكل مهم ديني كالجمعة والجماعة، أو دنيوي مباح، كاقتضاء الغريم، فليس له الخروج لأجل الحرام.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 26
- Hanbali
According to the Hanbalis, if the person in retreat stipulates leaving for an unintended purpose like a walk, entertainment, or visiting his wife, does the vow contract? The Hanbalis said: if he stipulates leaving for something unintended like a walk, entertainment, or visiting his wife, his vow does not contract.
Applies when: if he stipulates leaving for an unintended purpose (غير مقصود) like a walk (نزهة), entertainment (فرجة), or visiting his wife (إتيان أهله)
The Arabic
وخرج بقوله "مقصود" ما لو شرطه، أو لغير مقصود كنزهة أو فرجة، كإتيان أهله، فإذا اشترط الخروج لشيء من ذلك فإنه لا ينعقد نذره.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 26
- All agreeHanbali
According to the Hanbalis, if the person in retreat stipulates leaving for buying, selling, renting, or earning through a craft in the mosque, is the stipulation valid? The Hanbalis said: the stipulation is not valid, without disagreement.
Applies when: if he stipulates leaving for buying and selling (البيع والشراء), renting (الإجارة), or earning through a craft in the mosque (التكسب بالصناعة في المسجد)
The Arabic
وقال الحنابلة: لو اشترط الخروج للبيع والشراء أو الإجارة، أو التكسب بالصناعة في المسجد لم يصح الشرط بلا خلاف.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 26
- Hanbali
According to the Hanbalis, if the person in retreat says 'when I become ill or an obstacle occurs I will leave', is his stipulation valid? The Hanbalis said: he may stipulate it according to the soundest view of the school.
Applies when: if he says 'when I become ill or an obstacle occurs I will leave' (متى مرضت أو عرض لي عارض خرجت)
The Arabic
ولو قال: متى مرضت أو عرض لي عارض خرجت فله شرطه على الصحيح من المذهب.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 26
- Shafi'i
According to the Shafi'is, in the case of continuous retreat, if a condition is stipulated, must the person make up what he missed? The Shafi'is said: in continuous retreat, he does not have to make up what he missed, as if he vowed 'this month except such-and-such'.
Applies when: in continuous retreat (الاعتكاف المتتابع) when a condition is stipulated
The Arabic
ومحل ذلك في الاعتكاف المتتابع عند الشافعية، ولا يلزمه تدارك ما فاته، فكأنه قال: نذرت هذا الشهر إلا كذا.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 26
- Hanbali
According to the Hanbalis, what is the benefit of a stipulation in retreat? The Hanbalis said: the benefit of the stipulation is the dropping of the make-up for the specified period.
Applies when: when a stipulation is made
The Arabic
أما عند الحنابلة فإن فائدة الشرط عندهم سقوط القضاء في المدة المعينة.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 26
- Hanbali
According to the Hanbalis, if one vows a continuous month, may he leave except for illness, and must he make up the illness period? The Hanbalis said: if one vows a continuous month, he may not leave except for illness, and he must make up the period of illness, because the stipulation can be interpreted as negating continuity only, so it is applied minimally, and the stipulation here benefits building (continuity) with dropping of make-up.
Applies when: if one vows a continuous month (نذر شهرا متتابعا) and stipulates a condition
The Arabic
أما لو نذر شهرا متتابعا، فلا يجوز الخروج منه إلا لمرض، وعليه قضاء زمن المرض، لإمكان حمل شرطه هنا على نفي التتابع فقط، فنزل على الأقل، ويكون الشرط قد أفاد هنا البناء مع سقوط القضاء.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 26
What breaks it: intercourse and what leads to it
- All agree
Is sexual intercourse during i'tikaf forbidden and does it invalidate it? Agreed: it is forbidden and invalidates i'tikaf if done intentionally, whether by night or day.
Applies when: if done intentionally, whether by night or day
The Arabic
اتفق الفقهاء على أن الجماع في الاعتكاف حرام ومبطل له، ليلا كان أو نهارا، إن كان عامدا.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 27
- Majority
Does sexual intercourse during i'tikaf invalidate it if done forgetfully? The majority hold that it does invalidate it.
Applies when: if done forgetfully (ناسيا لاعتكافه)
The Arabic
وكذا إن فعله ناسيا لاعتكافه عند الجمهور
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 27
- Shafi'i
Does sexual intercourse during i'tikaf invalidate it if done forgetfully? The Shafi'is hold that it is only forbidden and invalidates if the person knows it is forbidden and remembers being in i'tikaf.
Applies when: only if the person knows it is forbidden and remembers being in i'tikaf
The Arabic
وذهب الشافعية إلى أن حرمة الجماع وإفساده للاعتكاف لا يكون إلا من عالم بتحريمه ذاكر للاعتكاف
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 27
- HanafiHanbali
Do the preliminaries of intercourse (touching, kissing) invalidate i'tikaf? The Hanafis and Hanbalis hold that they do invalidate it.
Applies when: for the preliminaries of intercourse (اللمس والقبلة)
The Arabic
وأما دواعي الجماع كاللمس والقبلة، فإنها تفسد الاعتكاف عند الحنفية والحنابلة
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 27
- Shafi'i
Do the preliminaries of intercourse (touching, kissing) invalidate i'tikaf? The most apparent view among the Shafi'is is that they invalidate it if ejaculation occurs.
Applies when: if ejaculation occurs (إذا أنزل)
The Arabic
وهو الأظهر للشافعية إذا أنزل
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 27
- Shafi'i (one view)
Do the preliminaries of intercourse (touching, kissing) invalidate i'tikaf? According to one of the other two Shafi'i views, they invalidate it absolutely.
Applies when: absolutely (مطلقا)
The Arabic
والقولان الآخران للشافعية أنه يبطل مطلقا
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 27
- Shafi'i (one view)
Do the preliminaries of intercourse (touching, kissing) invalidate i'tikaf? According to another Shafi'i view, they do not invalidate it.
The Arabic
وقيل: لا يبطل
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 27
- Maliki
Do kissing, touching, or direct contact with desire invalidate i'tikaf? The Malikis hold that if one kisses, touches, or has direct contact intending pleasure or experiencing it, i'tikaf is invalidated and must be restarted from the beginning.
Applies when: if one kisses, touches, or has direct contact intending pleasure or experiencing it
The Arabic
قال المالكية: إنه إذا قبل وقصد اللذة، أو لمس، أو باشر بقصدها، أو وجدها بطل اعتكافه، واستأنفه من أوله
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 27
- Maliki
Does kissing a young girl who is not desired, or kissing one's wife for farewell or mercy without intending or experiencing pleasure, invalidate i'tikaf? The Malikis hold that it does not invalidate it.
Applies when: if one kisses a young girl not desired, or kisses his wife for farewell or mercy without intending or experiencing pleasure
The Arabic
فلو قبل صغيرة لا تشتهى، أو قبل زوجته لوداع أو رحمة، ولم يقصد لذة ولا وجدها لم يبطل
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 27
- Maliki
Is the condition of desire required for kissing outside the mouth to invalidate i'tikaf? According to the Malikis, desire is required for kissing outside the mouth, but for kissing on the mouth desire is not required on the apparent view.
Applies when: kissing outside the mouth vs. kissing on the mouth
The Arabic
ثم إن اشتراط الشهوة في القبلة إذا كانت في غير الفم، وأما إذا كانت فيه فلا تشترط الشهوة على الظاهر
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 27
- Maliki
Is sexual intercourse in the mosque forbidden? The Malikis state that it is absolutely forbidden due to the mosque's sanctity.
Applies when: in the mosque absolutely
The Arabic
وقد نصوا على تحريم الوطء في المسجد مطلقا لكرامته
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 27
- Maliki
Does sexual intercourse by a female mu'takif invalidate her i'tikaf? The Malikis hold that it invalidates it.
Applies when: for a female mu'takif
The Arabic
وطء المعتكفة مفسد لاعتكافها
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 27
- Majority
Is expiation required for sexual intercourse that invalidates a consecutive vowed i'tikaf? The majority hold that no expiation is required.
Applies when: for a mu'takif who remembers his i'tikaf and knows it is forbidden, in a consecutive vowed i'tikaf
The Arabic
وذهب الجمهور إلى أن الجماع المفسد للاعتكاف المنذور المتتابع من المعتكف الذاكر له العالم بتحريمه لا تلزمه الكفارة.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 27
- Majority
Is expiation required for sexual intercourse that invalidates i'tikaf? Ibn al-Mundhir reports that most scholars hold that no expiation is required, and it is the view of the people of Medina, Syria, and Iraq.
The Arabic
قال ابن المنذر: أكثر أهل العلم على أنه لا كفارة عليه، وهو قول أهل المدينة والشام والعراق.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 27
- All agree
Is expiation required for sexual intercourse that invalidates i'tikaf? Al-Mawardi reports that all jurists hold no expiation except al-Hasan al-Basri and al-Zuhri, who said expiation is like that of one who has intercourse during Ramadan.
The Arabic
قال الماوردي هو قول جميع الفقهاء إلا الحسن البصري والزهري، فقالا: عليه كفارة الواطئ في صوم رمضان.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 27
- Other scholars
Is expiation required for sexual intercourse that invalidates i'tikaf? Al-Hasan has another narration that he must free a slave; if unable, sacrifice a camel; if unable, give charity with twenty sa' of dates.
The Arabic
وعن الحسن رواية أخرى هي أنه يعتق رقبة، فإن عجز أهدى بدنة، فإن عجز تصدق بعشرين صاعا من تمر.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 27
- Other scholars
Is expiation required for sexual intercourse that invalidates i'tikaf? Qadi Abu Ya'la said it is the expiation of zihar.
The Arabic
وقال القاضي أبو يعلى: هي كفارة الظهار
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 27
- Other scholars
Is expiation required for sexual intercourse that invalidates i'tikaf? Abu Bakr said it is the expiation of a broken oath.
The Arabic
وقال أبو بكر: هي كفارة يمين.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 27
What breaks it: leaving the mosque
In short
- All agreeHanafiinvalidates obligatory iʿtikāf
- Hanafi (one view)Malikiinvalidates recommended iʿtikāf
- All agreedoes not invalidate iʿtikāf
- All agreeHanafi
The jurists agree that leaving the mosque for a man or a woman (and likewise a woman leaving her mosque at home according to the Hanafis) for no need invalidates obligatory iʿtikāf.
Applies when: leaving the mosque for no need
The Arabic
اتفق الفقهاء على أن الخروج من المسجد للرجل والمرأة (وكذلك خروج المرأة من مسجد بيتها عند الحنفية) إذا كان لغير حاجة فإنه يفسد الاعتكاف الواجب
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 28
- Hanafi (one view)Maliki
The Malikis and Abu Hanifa in a narration from al-Hasan extend the ruling of obligatory iʿtikāf to recommended iʿtikāf, so leaving for no need invalidates it as well.
Applies when: leaving for no need, whether the exit is small or large
The Arabic
وألحق المالكية وأبو حنيفة - في رواية الحسن عنه - بالواجب الاعتكاف المندوب أيضا، سواء أكان الخروج يسيرا أم كثيرا
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 28
- All agree
All jurists agree that leaving for a need does not invalidate iʿtikāf.
Applies when: leaving for a need
The Arabic
أما إذا كان الخروج لحاجة فلا يبطل الاعتكاف في قولهم جميعا
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 28
Leaving to relieve oneself, for wudu and for obligatory ghusl
- All agree
The jurists agree that leaving to relieve oneself and for obligatory ghusl does not harm iʿtikāf.
Applies when: leaving to relieve oneself or for obligatory ghusl
The Arabic
اتفق الفقهاء على أنه لا يضر الخروج لقضاء الحاجة والغسل الذي وجب مما لا يفسد الاعتكاف
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 29
- Other scholars
If the person stays long after leaving for a need, his iʿtikāf is invalidated.
Applies when: prolonged stay after leaving for a need
The Arabic
لكن إن طال مكثه بعد ذلك فسد اعتكافه
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 29
- All agree
Ibn al-Mundhir reports that the scholars agree that a person in iʿtikāf may leave his place of iʿtikāf for defecation and urination.
Applies when: leaving for defecation or urination
The Arabic
قال ابن المنذر: أجمع أهل العلم على أن للمعتكف أن يخرج من معتكفه للغائط والبول
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 29
- HanafiHanbali
According to the Hanafis and Hanbalis, the person in iʿtikāf may perform ghusl, wuḍūʾ, and wash in the mosque if he does not soil it.
Applies when: if he does not soil the mosque
The Arabic
وله الغسل والوضوء والاغتسال في المسجد إذا لم يلوث المسجد عند الحنفية والحنابلة
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 29
- Shafi'i
According to the Shafiʿis, if it is possible to perform wuḍūʾ in the mosque, it is not permissible to leave (for it) in the sounder view; a second view permits it.
Applies when: if wuḍūʾ can be done in the mosque
The Arabic
وعند الشافعية إن أمكنه الوضوء في المسجد لا يجوز له الخروج في الأصح، والثاني يجوز
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 29
- Maliki
The Malikis consider it disliked for a person in iʿtikāf to enter his family's home (i.e., his wife) when he goes out to relieve himself, lest something occur between them that invalidates his iʿtikāf.
Applies when: when going out to relieve oneself, entering the home where his wife is
The Arabic
وذهب المالكية إلى كراهة دخول منزل أهله وبه أهله - أي زوجته - إذا خرج لقضاء الحاجة
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 29
- Shafi'iHanbali
According to the Shafiʿis and Hanbalis, if a person has two homes, he must go to the nearer one when leaving for a need.
Applies when: if he has two homes
The Arabic
أما إذا كان له منزلان فيلزمه أقربهما عند الشافعية والحنابلة
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 29
- Other scholars
If there is a water place (miḍaʾa) that one is too shy to use, he is not required to purify himself there, nor is he required to purify himself in a friend's house, because that violates dignity and incurs obligation.
Applies when: if one is too shy to use the available water place
The Arabic
وإذا كانت هناك ميضأة يحتشم منها لا يكلف التطهر منها، ولا يكلف الطهارة في بيت صديقه
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 29
- Other scholars
If one is not shy of the water place, he is required to use it.
Applies when: if one is not shy of the water place
The Arabic
أما إذا كان لا يحتشم من الميضأة فيكلفها
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 29
- All agree
All jurists agree that leaving for vomiting or removing impurity does not invalidate iʿtikāf.
Applies when: leaving for vomiting or removing impurity
The Arabic
وألحقوا بالخروج لما تقدم الخروج للقيء وإزالة النجاسة، فلا يفسد الاعتكاف أيضا في قولهم جميعا
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 29
- Other scholars
One who goes out for a need is not required to hurry; he may walk at his usual pace.
Applies when: when going out for a need
The Arabic
ولا يكلف الذي خرج لحاجة الإسراع، بل له المشي على عادته
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 29
Leaving to eat and drink
In short
- HanafiMalikiHanbaliinvalidates iʿtikāf if someone can bring food; permitted if no one can bring it
- Shafi'iHanbalipermitted
- Shafi'ipermitted only in a frequented mosque; not permitted in a deserted mosque
- HanafiMalikiHanbali
Does leaving the mosque for eating and drinking break iʿtikāf? The Ḥanafīs, Mālikīs, and Ḥanbalīs hold that leaving for eating and drinking invalidates iʿtikāf if someone can bring the food to him, because there is no necessity to go out; but if he cannot find anyone to bring it, he may go out, because it is an unavoidable exit.
Applies when: when there is someone who can bring food/drink to him; otherwise, when he cannot find anyone to bring it
The Arabic
ذهب الحنفية والمالكية والحنابلة إلى أن الخروج للأكل والشرب يفسد اعتكافه إذا كان هناك من يأتيه به لعدم الضرورة إلى الخروج، أما إذا لم يجد من يأتيه به فله الخروج
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 30
- Shafi'iHanbali
Does leaving the mosque for eating and drinking break iʿtikāf? The Shāfiʿīs and al-Qāḍī from the Ḥanbalīs hold that it is permissible to go out for eating, because eating in the mosque is embarrassing; likewise for drinking if there is no water in the mosque.
Applies when: for eating; for drinking if there is no water in the mosque
The Arabic
وذهب الشافعية والقاضي من الحنابلة إلى أنه يجوز له الخروج للأكل، لأن الأكل في المسجد يستحيا منه. وكذا للشرب إذا لم يكن في المسجد ماء
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 30
- Shafi'i
Does leaving the mosque for eating break iʿtikāf? The Shāfiʿīs specify that going out for eating is permissible only if his iʿtikāf is in a frequented mosque; if the mosque is deserted, he has no right to go out.
Applies when: if the mosque is frequented (مطروق); if the mosque is deserted (مهجور) then not permitted
The Arabic
وخص الشافعية جواز الخروج للأكل إذا كان اعتكافه في مسجد مطروق، أما إذا كان المسجد مهجورا فلا يحق له الخروج
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 30
Leaving for the Friday and Eid bath
In short
- Malikidoes not invalidate iʿtikāf
- Shafi'iHanbalinot permissible without stipulation; permissible if stipulated
- Maliki
Does leaving for the bath of Friday and Eid break iʿtikāf? The Mālikīs hold that the person in iʿtikāf may go out for the bath of Friday and Eid and for heat that afflicts him, and that does not invalidate iʿtikāf, contrary to the majority.
Applies when: for the bath of Friday and Eid, and for heat that afflicts him
The Arabic
ذهب المالكية إلى أن للمعتكف الخروج لغسل الجمعة والعيد ولحر أصابه فلا يفسد الاعتكاف خلافا للجمهور
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 31
- Shafi'iHanbali
Does leaving for the bath of Friday and Eid break iʿtikāf? The Shāfiʿīs and Ḥanbalīs state that it is not permissible to go out for the bath of Friday and Eid, because it is supererogatory and not obligatory and not a matter of necessity; but if he stipulates that, it is permissible.
Applies when: for the bath of Friday and Eid; if he stipulates it, it becomes permissible
The Arabic
وصرح الشافعية والحنابلة بأنه لا يجوز الخروج لغسل الجمعة والعيد، لأنه نفل وليس بواجب وليس من باب الضرورة. فإن اشترط ذلك جاز
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 31
Leaving for Friday prayer
In short
- Other scholarssinful if he does not go out; must go out
- HanafiHanbalidoes not invalidate iʿtikāf
- MalikiShafi'iinvalidates iʿtikāf; must restart
- Shafi'idoes not invalidate iʿtikāf if stipulated
- Hanafigo out at zawāl
- Hanbalipermissible to go early
- All agreerecommended to hasten back; not obligatory; staying after is disliked (makrūh tanzīhan)
- Other scholars
Is a person who has iʿtikāf in a mosque where Friday prayer is not held sinful, and must he go out for Friday prayer? The passage states that whoever is obligated to attend Friday prayer and his iʿtikāf is continuous and he performs iʿtikāf in a mosque where Friday prayer is not held is sinful, and he must go out for Friday prayer because it is an obligation.
Applies when: when Friday prayer is obligatory on him, his iʿtikāf is continuous, and the mosque does not hold Friday prayer
The Arabic
من وجبت عليه الجمعة، وكان اعتكافه متتابعا، واعتكف في مسجد لا تقام فيه الجمعة فهو آثم، ويجب عليه الخروج لصلاة الجمعة، لأنها فرض
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 32
- HanafiHanbali
Does leaving for Friday prayer break iʿtikāf? The Ḥanafīs and Ḥanbalīs hold that going out for Friday prayer does not invalidate iʿtikāf, because it is an unavoidable exit like going out to relieve oneself; Saʿīd ibn Jubayr, al-Ḥasan al-Baṣrī, al-Nakhaʿī, Aḥmad, ʿAbd al-Malik ibn al-Mājishūn, and Ibn al-Mundhir also held this view.
Applies when: when going out for Friday prayer
The Arabic
فإذا خرج للجمعة فقد ذهب الحنفية والحنابلة إلى أن خروجه للجمعة لا يفسد اعتكافه، لأنه خروج لما لا بد منه، كالخروج لقضاء الحاجة. وبه قال سعيد بن جبير والحسن البصري والنخعي وأحمد وعبد الملك بن الماجشون وابن المنذر
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 32
- MalikiShafi'i
Does leaving for Friday prayer break iʿtikāf? The Mālikīs in the well-known view and the Shāfiʿīs hold that the person in iʿtikāf going out for Friday prayer invalidates his iʿtikāf and he must start over, because he could avoid going out by performing iʿtikāf in the congregational mosque; if he does not do so and goes out, his iʿtikāf is invalid.
Applies when: when going out for Friday prayer without stipulating it
The Arabic
وذهب المالكية في المشهور عندهم والشافعية إلى أن خروج المعتكف لصلاة الجمعة يفسد اعتكافه وعليه الاستئناف، لأنه يمكنه الاحتراز من الخروج، بأن يعتكف في المسجد الجامع، فإذا لم يفعل وخرج بطل اعتكافه
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 32
- Shafi'i
Does leaving for Friday prayer break iʿtikāf if stipulated? The Shāfiʿīs except the case where he stipulates going out for Friday prayer in his iʿtikāf; if he stipulates it, it is valid and his iʿtikāf is not invalidated by going out.
Applies when: if he stipulates going out for Friday prayer in his iʿtikāf
The Arabic
واستثنى الشافعية ما لو شرط الخروج في اعتكافه لصلاة الجمعة، فإن شرطه يصح، ولا يبطل اعتكافه بخروجه
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 32
- Hanafi
When should one go out for Friday prayer? The Ḥanafīs hold that going out for Friday prayer is at the time of zawāl (noon), and from the place of his iʿtikāf he goes out at a time to catch it.
Applies when: for Friday prayer
The Arabic
وذهب الحنفية إلى أن الخروج لصلاة الجمعة يكون وقت الزوال، ومن بعد مسجد اعتكافه خرج في وقت يدركها
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 32
- Hanbali
When should one go out for Friday prayer? The Ḥanbalīs say that it is permissible to go early for it.
Applies when: for Friday prayer
The Arabic
أما الحنابلة فإنهم قالوا بجواز التبكير إليها
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 32
- All agree
Is it recommended or obligatory to return quickly after Friday prayer? They agreed that after Friday prayer it is recommended to hasten back to the place of iʿtikāf, but it is not obligatory to hasten because it is a place for iʿtikāf, and it is disliked (makrūh tanzīhan) to stay after Friday prayer without necessity, as it contradicts what he committed to.
Applies when: after Friday prayer
The Arabic
واتفقوا على أن المستحب بعد صلاة الجمعة التعجيل بالرجوع إلى مكان الاعتكاف. لكن لا يجب عليه التعجيل لأنه محل للاعتكاف، وكره تنزيها المكث بعد صلاة الجمعة لمخالفة ما التزمه بلا ضرورة
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 32
Leaving to visit the sick and pray a funeral prayer
In short
- All agreeHanafiShafi'iHanbalinot permissible
- Majoritypermissible
- Other scholarsdoes not invalidate i'tikaf
- Malikiinvalidates i'tikaf (but obligatory to leave for parents)
- All agreeHanafiShafi'iHanbali
The jurists agree that it is not permissible to leave i'tikaf to visit the sick or attend a funeral prayer unless there is necessity, except if one stipulated the condition to leave for these purposes according to the Hanafis, Shafi'is, and Hanbalis.
Applies when: unless necessity or prior stipulation (Hanafis, Shafi'is, Hanbalis)
The Arabic
اتفق الفقهاء على عدم جواز الخروج لعيادة المريض وصلاة الجنازة لعدم الضرورة إلى الخروج، إلا إذا اشترط الخروج لهما عند الحنفية والشافعية والحنابلة.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 33
- Majority
According to the majority, if one leaves for a need and then stops by a patient or a funeral prayer, it is permissible provided he does not stay long, i.e., only as long as a greeting.
Applies when: leaving for a need and then stopping by, without prolonged stay
The Arabic
أما إذا خرج لقضاء الحاجة ثم عرج على مريض لعيادته، أو لصلاة الجنازة، فإنه يجوز بشرط ألا يطول مكثه عند المريض، أو بعد صلاة الجنازة عند الجمهور، بأن لا يقف عند المريض إلا بقدر السلام
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 33
- Other scholars
According to Abu Yusuf and Muhammad, i'tikaf is not invalidated if the absence is not more than half a day.
Applies when: absence not more than half a day
The Arabic
وعند أبي يوسف ومحمد لا ينتقض الاعتكاف إذا لم يكن أكثر من نصف النهار.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 33
- Maliki
According to the Malikis, i'tikaf is invalidated by leaving to visit a sick person or attend a funeral, but they obligate leaving to visit one or both sick parents, and the i'tikaf is invalidated and must be made up.
Applies when: leaving to visit a sick parent or both
The Arabic
أما المالكية فإنهم مع الجمهور في فساد الاعتكاف لخروج عيادة المريض وصلاة الجنازة، إلا أنهم أوجبوا الخروج لعيادة أحد الأبوين المريضين أو كليهما، وذلك لبرهما فإنه آكد من الاعتكاف المنذور، ويبطل اعتكافه به ويقضيه.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 33
Leaving forgetfully
In short
- HanafiMalikiinvalidates i'tikaf
- Shafi'iHanbalidoes not invalidate i'tikaf
- HanafiMaliki
According to the Hanafis and Malikis, leaving the mosque intentionally or forgetfully invalidates i'tikaf.
Applies when: leaving intentionally or forgetfully
The Arabic
ذهب الحنفية والمالكية إلى أن الخروج من المسجد عمدا أو سهوا يبطل الاعتكاف.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 34
- Shafi'iHanbali
According to the Shafi'is and Hanbalis, i'tikaf is not invalidated if one leaves forgetfully.
Applies when: leaving forgetfully
The Arabic
وذهب الشافعية والحنابلة إلى عدم البطلان إذا خرج ناسيا
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 34
Leaving to give testimony
In short
- HanafiMalikiinvalidates i'tikaf
- Malikimust not leave; must testify in mosque
- Shafi'iHanbaliobligatory to leave; does not invalidate i'tikaf
- Shafi'iHanbaliinvalidates i'tikaf
- HanafiMaliki
According to the Hanafis and Malikis, leaving i'tikaf to give testimony invalidates i'tikaf.
Applies when: leaving to give testimony
The Arabic
ذهب الحنفية والمالكية إلى أن الخروج لأجل الشهادة مفسد للاعتكاف.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 35
- Maliki
According to the Malikis, one who is obliged to give testimony (no one else can do it) must not leave the mosque but must give testimony inside the mosque or have it transmitted.
Applies when: testimony is obligatory and no one else can give it
The Arabic
وصرح المالكية بأن من وجبت عليه شهادة، بألا يكون هناك غيره، أو لا يتم النصاب إلا به، لا يخرج من المسجد لأدائها، بل يجب أن يؤديها في المسجد إما بحضور القاضي، أو تنقل عنه.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 35
- Shafi'iHanbali
According to the Shafi'is and Hanbalis, one must leave i'tikaf to give testimony when it becomes obligatory, and he sins if he does not leave; likewise for bearing testimony if it becomes obligatory, and i'tikaf is not invalidated by that exit because it is an obligatory exit according to the soundest view of the Shafi'is.
Applies when: testimony or bearing testimony is obligatory (تعينت)
The Arabic
وذهب الشافعية والحنابلة إلى أنه يلزمه الخروج لأداء الشهادة متى تعينت عليه ويأثم بعدم الخروج، وكذلك التحمل للشهادة إذا تعين، فيجوز له الخروج ولا يبطل اعتكافه بذلك الخروج، لأنه خروج واجب على الأصح عند الشافعية
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 35
- Shafi'iHanbali
According to the Shafi'is and Hanbalis, if giving a testimony is not his personal duty (others can give it), leaving the mosque to give it breaks his i'tikaf.
Applies when: testimony is not obligatory
The Arabic
أما إذا لم تتعين عليه، فيبطل اعتكافه بالخروج.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 35
Leaving because of illness
In short
- Other scholarsnot permitted, invalidates
- Hanafiinvalidates
- MalikiHanbalidoes not invalidate, does not break consecutiveness
- Shafi'idoes not invalidate (most correct view)
- Other scholarsdoes not break consecutiveness
- All agreedoes not break i'tikaf
- Other scholarsinvalidated, must start over
- Shafi'icount as part of i'tikaf
- Other scholars
For a minor illness that does not make staying in the mosque difficult (e.g., headache, mild fever), leaving the mosque is not permitted if the i'tikaf is a vowed consecutive one; if he leaves, his i'tikaf is invalidated because he is not compelled to do so.
Applies when: minor illness, vowed consecutive i'tikaf
The Arabic
المرض اليسير الذي لا تشق معه الإقامة في المسجد كصداع وحمى خفيفة وغيرهما لا يجوز معه الخروج من المسجد إذا كان اعتكافه منذورا متتابعا، فإن خرج فسد اعتكافه لأنه غير مضطر إليه.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 36
- Hanafi
The Hanafis hold that leaving the mosque due to a severe illness that makes staying impossible (e.g., needing care, bed, or a doctor) invalidates the i'tikaf.
Applies when: severe illness, vowed consecutive i'tikaf
The Arabic
ذهب الحنفية إلى أن خروجه مفسد لاعتكافه
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 37
- MalikiHanbali
The Malikis and Hanbalis hold that leaving due to a severe illness does not invalidate the i'tikaf and does not break the consecutiveness; he may resume after recovery.
Applies when: severe illness
The Arabic
وذهب المالكية والحنابلة إلى أنه لا يبطل ولا ينقطع به التتابع، ويبني على ما مضى إذا شفي
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 37
- Shafi'i
The Shafi'is consider the view that leaving due to severe illness does not invalidate i'tikaf as the most correct (al-asahh).
Applies when: severe illness
The Arabic
وهو الأصح عند الشافعية
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 37
- Other scholars
If the illness causes impurity in the mosque (e.g., vomiting), leaving does not break the consecutiveness of i'tikaf.
Applies when: illness that soils the mosque (e.g., vomiting)
The Arabic
وكذلك إذا كان المرض مما يتلوث به المسجد كالقيء ونحوه فإنه لا ينقطع به التتابع
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 37
- All agree
All jurists agree that leaving the mosque during unconsciousness does not break i'tikaf because he did not leave voluntarily.
Applies when: unconsciousness
The Arabic
أما الخروج حالة الإغماء فإنه لا يقطع الاعتكاف في قولهم جميعا، لأنه لم يخرج باختياره
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 37
- Other scholars
Al-Kasani states that if someone is unconscious for days or suffers from epilepsy (madness), his i'tikaf is invalidated and he must start over when cured, because it was a vowed consecutive i'tikaf.
Applies when: unconsciousness for days or epilepsy, vowed consecutive i'tikaf
The Arabic
وإن أغمي عليه أياما، أو أصابه لمم (جنون) فسد اعتكافه، وعليه إذا برأ أن يستقبل، لأنه لزمه متتابعا
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 37
- Shafi'i
According to the Shafi'is, illness and unconsciousness count as part of the i'tikaf (i.e., do not break it), and fear of a thief or fire is treated in the same way as illness.
Applies when: illness, unconsciousness, fear of thief or fire
The Arabic
وعند الشافعية أن المرض والإغماء يحسبان من الاعتكاف وفي معنى المرض هذا، الخوف من لص أو حريق عند الشافعية
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 37
Leaving because the mosque collapses
- Hanafi
If the mosque collapses and the person leaves to continue his i'tikaf in another mosque, that is valid according to the Hanafis (by istihsan) and likewise according to others.
Applies when: mosque collapses, moves to another mosque
The Arabic
إذا انهدم المسجد فخرج منه ليقيم اعتكافه في مسجد آخر صح ذلك عند الحنفية استحسانا، وكذلك عند غيرهم.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 38
Leaving under coercion
In short
- All agreedoes not invalidate
- Hanafidoes not invalidate (if enters another mosque immediately); otherwise invalidates
- All agree
The jurists agree that leaving due to coercion by a government authority does not invalidate i'tikaf before its completion.
Applies when: coercion by government authority
The Arabic
اتفق الفقهاء على أن الخروج بسبب الإكراه لحكومة لا يفسد الاعتكاف قبل تمام الاعتكاف.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 39
- Hanafi
The Hanafis state that coercion does not invalidate i'tikaf if the person enters another mosque immediately; this is recommended (istihbab) from them; if he does not enter another mosque, the original ruling of invalidation applies.
Applies when: coercion, entering another mosque immediately or not
The Arabic
إلا أن الحنفية أطلقوا القول بأن الإكراه لا يفسد الاعتكاف إذا دخل المعتكف مسجدا آخر من ساعته. وهذا استحباب منهم، أما إذا لم يدخل مسجدا آخر، فيبقى الحكم على أصل القياس وهو البطلان.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 39
Leaving without an excuse
- Hanafi
If a person leaves i'tikaf without any excuse, his i'tikaf is invalidated, even if the time of leaving is brief, except according to Abu Yusuf and Muhammad of the Hanafis, who restrict the invalidating period to more than half the day.
Applies when: leaving without excuse, brief time
The Arabic
أما إذا خرج المعتكف بدون عذر فسد اعتكافه ... ولو كان زمن الخروج يسيرا، إلا عند أبي يوسف ومحمد من الحنفية، فإنهما قيدا زمن المفسد بأكثر من نصف النهار.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 40
What counts as leaving the mosque
- Other scholars
The limit of leaving the mosque for a person in iʿtikāf is that he exits with his entire body; if he exits with only part of his body, it does not harm his iʿtikāf.
Applies when: when a person in iʿtikāf exits the mosque with only part of his body
The Arabic
حد الخروج من المسجد أن يخرج بجميع جسده، فإن خرج ببعضه لم يضر
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 41
What counts as part of the mosque
In short
- All agreevalid
- HanafiMalikiHanbalinot part of the mosque
- Hanbalipart of the mosque
- Hanbalipart of the mosque
- Shafi'ivalid
- All agreepermissible
- HanafiShafi'iHanbalipart of the mosque
- Shafi'ivalid
- Hanafipermissible
- Shafi'ipermissible for the regular muezzin, not for others
- All agree
The jurists agree that the mosque in which iʿtikāf is valid is a building prepared for prayer.
Applies when: the mosque is a building prepared for prayer
The Arabic
اتفق الفقهاء على أن المراد بالمسجد الذي يصح فيه الاعتكاف، ما كان بناء معدا للصلاة فيه
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 42
- HanafiMalikiHanbali
According to the Ḥanafīs, Mālikīs, and the correct view of the Ḥanbalī school, the courtyard (raḥbah) of the mosque is not part of the mosque for iʿtikāf.
Applies when: the courtyard (raḥbah) is an enclosed area added near the mosque for expansion
The Arabic
الذي يفهم من كلام الحنفية والمالكية والحنابلة في الصحيح من المذهب أنها ليست من المسجد
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 42
- Hanbali
The opposite view in the Ḥanbalī school holds that the courtyard (raḥbah) of the mosque is part of the mosque.
Applies when: the courtyard (raḥbah) is an enclosed area added near the mosque for expansion
The Arabic
ومقابل الصحيح عندهم أنها من المسجد
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 42
- Hanbali
Is a mosque's courtyard part of the mosque for i'tikaf? The Hanbali Abu Ya'la reconciled the two narrations from Ahmad: a courtyard that is walled in and has a door is part of the mosque.
Applies when: the courtyard (raḥbah) is enclosed and has a door
The Arabic
وجمع أبو يعلى بين الروايتين بأن الرحبة المحوطة وعليها باب هي من المسجد
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 42
- Shafi'i
The Shāfiʿīs hold that the courtyard (raḥbah) of the mosque is part of the mosque, so iʿtikāf in it is valid.
Applies when: iʿtikāf is performed in the courtyard (raḥbah) of the mosque
The Arabic
وذهب الشافعية إلى أن رحبة المسجد من المسجد، فلو اعتكف فيها صح اعتكافه
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 42
- All agree
Ibn Qudāmah said that it is permissible for a person in iʿtikāf to ascend the roof of the mosque, and he knows of no disagreement on this.
Applies when: a person in iʿtikāf ascending the roof of the mosque
The Arabic
قال ابن قدامة: يجوز للمعتكف صعود سطح المسجد، ولا نعلم فيه خلافا
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 42
- HanafiShafi'iHanbali
According to the Ḥanafīs, Shāfiʿīs, and Ḥanbalīs, if the minaret is inside the mosque or its door is inside the mosque, it is part of the mosque.
Applies when: the minaret is inside the mosque or its door is inside the mosque
The Arabic
أما المنارة فإن كانت في المسجد أو بابها فيه فهي من المسجد عند الحنفية والشافعية والحنابلة
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 42
- Shafi'i
According to the Shāfiʿīs, if the minaret's door is outside the mosque or in its courtyard, it is part of the mosque and iʿtikāf in it is valid.
Applies when: the minaret's door is outside the mosque or in its courtyard (raḥbah)
The Arabic
وإن كان بابها خارج المسجد أو في رحبته فهي منه، ويصح فيها الاعتكاف عند الشافعية
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 42
- Hanafi
According to the Ḥanafīs, if the minaret's door is outside the mosque, a person in iʿtikāf may give the adhān from it, whether he is the regular muezzin or not.
Applies when: the minaret's door is outside the mosque, and the person in iʿtikāf gives the adhān from it
The Arabic
وإن كان بابها خارج المسجد فيجوز أذان المعتكف فيها، سواء أكان مؤذنا أم غيره عند الحنفية
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 42
- Shafi'i
According to the Shāfiʿīs, if the minaret's door is outside the mosque, the regular muezzin may give the adhān from it while in iʿtikāf, but not others; al-Nawawī said this is the most correct view.
Applies when: the minaret's door is outside the mosque, and the person in iʿtikāf is the regular muezzin
The Arabic
وأما عند الشافعية فقد فرقوا بين المؤذن الراتب وغيره، فيجوز للراتب الأذان فيها وهو معتكف دون غيره، قال النووي: وهو الأصح
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 42
What breaks it: insanity
In short
- All agreedoes not invalidate
- Majoritydoes not break; continues upon recovery
- Hanafiby qiyās: no make-up; by istiḥsān: make-up required if insanity lasts a year or more
- Hanbalidisputed: continue or start anew
- All agree
If insanity (junūn) occurs to a person in iʿtikāf for a short time, it does not invalidate the iʿtikāf according to all jurists.
Applies when: insanity occurs for a short time
The Arabic
إذا طرأ على المعتكف الجنون، وكان زمنه قليلا فإنه لا يفسد الاعتكاف في قول الفقهاء جميعا
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 43
- Majority
If insanity lasts a long time, the majority (al-jumhūr) hold that it does not break the iʿtikāf, and when the person regains sanity he continues (builds upon it).
Applies when: insanity lasts a long time
The Arabic
أما إذا طال الجنون فالجمهور على أنه لا يقطع الاعتكاف، ومتى أفاق بنى
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 43
- Hanafi
The Ḥanafīs hold that by analogy (qiyās) the obligation to make up (qaḍāʾ) the iʿtikāf falls away, by analogy with the dropping of making up fasting when one becomes insane, but by istiḥsān he must make it up if his insanity lasts a year or more.
Applies when: insanity lasts a year or more
The Arabic
وذهب الحنفية إلى أن القياس سقوط القضاء قياسا على سقوط قضاء الصوم إذا جن، إلا أن الاستحسان أنه يقضي إذا طال جنونه سنة فأكثر
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 43
- Hanbali
The Ḥanbalīs differed on whether the person in iʿtikāf continues (builds upon it) or starts anew, based on their disagreement on the invalidity of fasting.
Applies when: insanity lasts a long time
The Arabic
واختلف الحنابلة فيه، هل يبني أو يبتدئ ؟ بناء على خلافهم في بطلان الصوم
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 43
What breaks it: apostasy
- All agreeHanafiMalikiShafi'iHanbali
Apostasy invalidates i'tikaf according to all jurists, but if the apostate repents and embraces Islam, the Hanafis, Malikis, and Hanbalis hold that restarting i'tikaf is not obligatory, while the Shafi'is hold that restarting is obligatory.
Applies when: after apostasy and subsequent repentance and Islam
The Arabic
ذهب الحنفية والمالكية والحنابلة إلى عدم وجوب الاستئناف بعد توبته ... ومذهب الشافعية وجوب الاستئناف.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 44
What breaks it: intoxication
In short
- HanafiMalikiShafi'iHanbaliinvalidates i'tikaf (Hanbalis, Malikis, Shafi'is when due to forbidden cause); does not invalidate if at night (Hanafis)
- Malikiinvalidates i'tikaf (like forbidden intoxication)
- HanafiMalikiShafi'iHanbali
The Hanbalis hold that intoxication with a forbidden substance invalidates i'tikaf; the Malikis and Shafi'is also hold this if the intoxication is due to a forbidden cause; the Hanafis do not consider it invalid if it occurs at night, but if it occurs during the day it invalidates the fast and thereby invalidates i'tikaf.
Applies when: intoxication with a forbidden substance; for Hanafis: night vs. day
The Arabic
ذهب الحنابلة إلى أن السكر بالحرام مفسد للاعتكاف، وعليه المالكية والشافعية إذا كان بسبب حرام. ولم يره الحنفية مفسدا إن وقع ليلا، أما إن كان في النهار فإنه يبطل الصوم فيبطل الاعتكاف
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 45
- Maliki
The Malikis include the use of a narcotic that causes stupefaction under the same ruling as forbidden intoxication.
Applies when: use of a narcotic that stupefies
The Arabic
وألحق المالكية بالسكر الحرام استعمال المخدر إذا خدره.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 45
What breaks it: menstruation and postnatal bleeding
In short
- Other scholarsmust leave mosque; forbidden to remain; must resume immediately and obligatorily; delay invalidates; time not counted
- Other scholarsdoes not leave if safe from soiling; leaving invalidates i'tikaf
- Shafi'icontinuity interrupted in the most apparent view if period could be free of menstruation; second view: not interrupted
- Hanbalileaves to her house if mosque has no courtyard
- Other scholars
A menstruating or postpartum woman must leave the mosque, as it is forbidden for her to remain there, and menstruation and postpartum bleeding break the fast; she must resume her i'tikaf immediately and obligatorily after the excuse ends in a consecutive vowed i'tikaf, and if she delays, the i'tikaf is invalidated; the time of menstruation and postpartum is not counted from the i'tikaf.
Applies when: menstruating or postpartum woman in i'tikaf; specifically for vowed consecutive i'tikaf
The Arabic
يجب على الحائض والنفساء الخروج من المسجد، إذ يحرم عليهما المكث فيه ... والحائض والنفساء يبنيان وجوبا وفورا - في نذر الاعتكاف المتتابع - بمجرد زوال العذر، فإذا تأخرتا بطل الاعتكاف. ولا يحسب زمن الحيض والنفاس من الاعتكاف.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 46
- Other scholars
A woman with istihadah (non-menstrual bleeding) does not leave her i'tikaf if she is safe from soiling; if she leaves, her i'tikaf is invalidated.
Applies when: woman with istihadah in i'tikaf
The Arabic
وأما المستحاضة، فإنها إن أمنت التلويث لم تخرج عن اعتكافها، فإن خرجت بطل اعتكافها.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 46
- Shafi'i
The Shafi'is condition that for i'tikaf not to be interrupted by menstruation or postpartum bleeding, the period of i'tikaf must not be such that it would be free of menstruation; if the period would be free of menstruation, then the continuity is interrupted in the most apparent view, because she could have started immediately after purity; the second view is that it is not interrupted because menstruation generally recurs and does not affect continuity like relieving oneself.
Applies when: menstruation or postpartum bleeding during a consecutive i'tikaf
The Arabic
وشرط الشافعية لعدم انقطاع الاعتكاف بالحيض والنفاس ألا تكون مدة الاعتكاف بحيث تخلو عن الحيض، فإن كانت مدة الاعتكاف بحيث تخلو عن الحيض انقطع التتابع في الأظهر ... والقول الثاني: لا ينقطع
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 46
- Hanbali
The Hanbalis say that a woman leaves for menstruation and postpartum to her house if the mosque has no courtyard, with details to be seen in their books.
Applies when: woman experiencing menstruation or postpartum bleeding during i'tikaf
The Arabic
وقال الحنابلة: تخرج المرأة للحيض والنفاس إلى بيتها إن لم يكن، للمسجد رحبة على تفصيل ينظر في كتبهم.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 46
What is allowed and disliked during i'tikaf
In short
- All agreedisliked (excessive speech/action); permitted (eating, drinking, sleeping in mosque)
- Malikidisliked
- Other scholarsmust sleep in mosque; leaving for sleep not permissible
- All agree
The jurists consider it disliked for the mu'takif to engage in excessive speech and action; eating, drinking, and sleeping in the mosque are permitted according to all of them.
Applies when: for the mu'takif
The Arabic
كره العلماء للمعتكف فضول القول والعمل ... يباح للمعتكف الأكل والشرب والنوم في المسجد في قولهم جميعا.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 47
- Maliki
The Malikis add that i'tikaf of one who cannot find someone to bring him his food and drink is disliked.
Applies when: mu'takif who cannot find someone to bring him food and drink
The Arabic
وزاد المالكية أن اعتكاف من لا يجد من يأتيه بحاجته من الطعام والشراب مكروه.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 47
- Other scholars
Sleeping for the mu'takif is to be in the mosque, because leaving for sleep is not an excuse, and no one mentioned that leaving for sleep is permissible.
Applies when: mu'takif sleeping
The Arabic
أما النوم للمعتكف فمحله المسجد، لأن خروجه للنوم ليس بعذر، ولم يذكر أحد أن الخروج للنوم جائز.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 47
Contracts and work in the mosque
In short
- HanafiShafi'ipermitted if needed, disliked if for trade
- Hanbalinot permitted except for necessities, invalidates iʿtikāf if he goes out for it
- Malikipermissible if without moving or prolonging, otherwise disliked
- Hanafiprohibitively disliked
- Malikidisliked if excessive, not objectionable if little
- Other scholarspermissible
- Shafi'inot disliked if little, disliked if excessive except writing knowledge
- Shafi'idisliked
- Hanbaliprohibited
- HanafiShafi'i
Is it permissible for a person in iʿtikāf to conclude contracts of sale, marriage, and revocable divorce? The Ḥanafīs and Shāfiʿīs explicitly permit it if needed for himself or his dependents, but if for trade it is disliked.
Applies when: if he needs it for himself or his dependents
The Arabic
يباح عقد البيع وعقد النكاح والرجعة، وبذلك صرح الحنفية والشافعية إذا احتاج إليه لنفسه أو عياله، فلو لتجارة كره
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 48
- Hanbali
According to the Ḥanbalīs, a person in iʿtikāf is not permitted to buy or sell except for what is indispensable for him outside the mosque without standing around; if he goes out for that purpose, his iʿtikāf is invalidated in all their views.
Applies when: except for what is indispensable outside the mosque without standing around
The Arabic
وعند الحنابلة لا يجوز للمعتكف البيع والشراء إلا لما لا بد له منه خارج المسجد من غير وقوف لذلك. أما إذا خرج لأجلها فسد اعتكافه في قولهم جميعا
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 48
- Maliki
According to the Mālikīs, it is permissible for a person in iʿtikāf to marry himself and to marry those under his guardianship in his sitting place inside the mosque without moving or prolonging the time; otherwise it is disliked.
Applies when: in his sitting place inside the mosque without moving or prolonging the time
The Arabic
وعند المالكية يجوز أن ينكح لنفسه، وأن ينكح من في ولايته في مجلسه داخل المسجد بغير انتقال ولا طول مدة، وإلا كره
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 48
- Hanafi
The Ḥanafīs explicitly state that bringing the sold item into the mosque is prohibitively disliked, because the mosque is protected from such things.
Applies when: bringing the sold item into the mosque
The Arabic
وصرح الحنفية بأن إحضار المبيع في المسجد مكروه تحريما، لأن المسجد محرز عن مثل ذلك
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 48
- Maliki
The Mālikīs hold that writing is disliked for a person in iʿtikāf, even if it is a Qurʾān or knowledge, if it is excessive; a little is not objectionable, though leaving it is better.
Applies when: for a person in iʿtikāf
The Arabic
وذهب المالكية إلى كراهة الكتابة للمعتكف وإن كان مصحفا أو علما إن كثر، ولا بأس باليسير وإن كان تركه أولى
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 49
- Other scholars
Ibn Wahb holds that it is permissible for a person in iʿtikāf to write the Qurʾān for reward, not for wages, but to read it and benefit those in need.
Applies when: for reward, not for wages
The Arabic
وعن ابن وهب أنه يجوز له كتابة المصحف للثواب لا للأجرة، بل ليقرأ فيه وينتفع من كان محتاجا
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 49
- Shafi'i
The Shāfiʿīs hold that crafts in the mosque, like sewing and writing, are not disliked for a person in iʿtikāf as long as he does not do them excessively; if he does them excessively, they are disliked due to the sanctity of the mosque, except writing knowledge, for which excess is not disliked because it is obedience for teaching knowledge.
Applies when: for a person in iʿtikāf
The Arabic
وذهب الشافعية إلى أنه لا يكره للمعتكف الصنائع في المسجد كالخياطة والكتابة ما لم يكثر منها، فإن أكثر منها كرهت لحرمته، إلا كتابة العلم، فلا يكره الإكثار منها، لأنها طاعة لتعليم العلم
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 49
- Shafi'i
According to the Shāfiʿīs, if a person in iʿtikāf practices sewing or transactions of buying and selling as a profession without need, it is disliked even if little.
Applies when: if done as a profession without need
The Arabic
أما إذا احترف الخياطة والمعاوضات من بيع وشراء بلا حاجة فتكره وإن قلت
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 49
- Hanbali
The Ḥanbalīs say that earning a living by a craft in the mosque, such as sewing and others, is prohibited, whether much or little, whether needy or not.
Applies when: earning a living by a craft in the mosque
The Arabic
وقال الحنابلة: يحرم التكسب بالصنعة في المسجد، كالخياطة وغيرها والكثير والقليل والمحتاج وغيره سواء
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 49
Silence
In short
- Hanafiprohibitively disliked if believed to be worship, otherwise not disliked
- Hanbalinot part of Islamic law
- Other scholarsdisliked
- Other scholarsprohibited
- Other scholarsforbidden if it omits obligatory speech, otherwise varies
- Hanafi
The Ḥanafīs hold that silence during iʿtikāf is prohibitively disliked if one believes it to be an act of worship; if one does not believe it to be worship, it is not disliked.
Applies when: during iʿtikāf, if one believes it to be an act of worship
The Arabic
ذهب الحنفية إلى أن الصمت مكروه تحريما حالة الاعتكاف إن اعتقده قربة، أما إذا لم يعتقده قربة فلا
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 50
- Hanbali
The Ḥanbalīs say that seeking closeness to God through silence is not part of the Islamic law.
Applies when: seeking closeness through silence
The Arabic
وقال الحنابلة: إن التقرب بالصمت ليس من شريعة الإسلام
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 50
- Other scholars
Ibn ʿAqīl holds that silence until night is disliked.
Applies when: silence until night
The Arabic
قال ابن عقيل: يكره الصمت إلى الليل
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 50
- Other scholars
Al-Muwaffaq and al-Majd say that the apparent meaning of the reports is that it is prohibited, and it is affirmed in al-Kāfī.
Applies when: silence until night (apparent from reports)
The Arabic
وقال الموفق والمجد: ظاهر الأخبار تحريمه، وجزم به في الكافي
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 50
- Other scholars
The verified position in al-Ikhtiyārāt is that if silence is prolonged to the point of omitting obligatory speech, it becomes forbidden; likewise if one deliberately remains silent about recommended speech; forbidden speech must be avoided by silence; idle talk should be avoided by silence; and if one vows silence, he should not fulfill it.
Applies when: if prolonged to omit obligatory speech, or deliberate silence about recommended speech
The Arabic
قال في الاختيارات: والتحقيق في الصمت أنه إن طال حتى تضمن ترك الكلام الواجب صار حراما، وكذا إن تعمد بالصمت عن الكلام المستحب، والكلام المحرم يجب الصمت عنه، وفضول الكلام ينبغي الصمت عنها، وإن نذر الصمت لم يف به
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 50
Speaking
- Hanafi
According to the Hanafis, it is prohibitively disliked for the person in iʿtikāf to speak except about good matters, meaning what involves no sin.
Applies when: for the person in iʿtikāf speaking except about good matters
The Arabic
قال الحنفية: يكره للمعتكف تحريما التكلم إلا بخير، وهو ما لا إثم فيه.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 51
- Maliki
According to the Malikis, occupying oneself with anything other than dhikr, recitation of the Qur'an, and prayer is disliked for the person in iʿtikāf, while performing these three is recommended.
Applies when: for the person in iʿtikāf
The Arabic
وعند المالكية أن الاشتغال بغير الذكر والتلاوة والصلاة مكروه، أما هذه الثلاثة ففعلها مستحب.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 51
- Hanbali
According to the Hanbalis, it is recommended for the person in iʿtikāf to avoid what does not concern him, such as argumentation, disputation, excessive speech, and the like.
Applies when: for the person in iʿtikāf
The Arabic
وقال الحنابلة: يستحب له اجتناب ما لا يعنيه من جدال ومراء وكثرة كلام وغيره
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 51
- MalikiHanbali
According to the Malikis and Hanbalis, it is disliked for the person in iʿtikāf to occupy himself with teaching knowledge, debating with jurists, and similar acts that are not acts of worship whose benefit is specific to him.
Applies when: for the person in iʿtikāf occupying himself with teaching, debating, etc., that are not acts of worship whose benefit is specific to him
The Arabic
ويكره عند المالكية والحنابلة للمعتكف الاشتغال بتدريس العلم ومناظرة الفقهاء ونحو ذلك من غير العبادات التي يختص نفعها به
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 51
- MalikiHanbali
According to Ibn Wahb of the Malikis and Abu al-Khattab of the Hanbalis, it is recommended for the person in iʿtikāf to occupy himself with teaching and debating if he intends obedience and not boasting.
Applies when: if the intention is obedience and not boasting
The Arabic
وعند ابن وهب من المالكية، وأبي الخطاب من الحنابلة استحباب ذلك لأنه من أنواع البر إذا قصد الطاعة لا المباهاة.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 51
- MalikiShafi'i
According to the Malikis and Shafi'is, it is permissible for the person in iʿtikāf to apply perfume of any kind, by night or day.
Applies when: for the person in iʿtikāf applying perfume
The Arabic
يجوز للمعتكف أن يتطيب بأنواع الطيب في ليل أو نهار عند المالكية والشافعية
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 52
- Maliki
According to the Malikis, it is permissible for both men and women in iʿtikāf to apply perfume, and this is the well-known view in their school.
Applies when: for both men and women in iʿtikāf
The Arabic
سواء أكان رجلا أم امرأة عند المالكية، وهو المشهور في مذهبهم.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 52
- MalikiShafi'i
According to the Malikis and Shafi'is, it is permissible for the person in iʿtikāf to trim nails and mustache.
Applies when: for the person in iʿtikāf trimming nails and mustache
The Arabic
وكذا يجوز عند المالكية والشافعية أخذ الظفر والشارب
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 52
- Maliki
According to the Malikis, the permissibility of trimming nails and mustache is conditional on being outside the mosque if one goes out for a valid excuse.
Applies when: if done outside the mosque when going out for a valid excuse
The Arabic
وقيد المالكية الجواز بكونه خارج المسجد إذا خرج لعذر.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 52
- Maliki
According to the Malikis, shaving the head is disliked for the person in iʿtikāf in all cases unless he is harmed (by not shaving).
Applies when: for the person in iʿtikāf shaving the head, except when harmed
The Arabic
أما حلق الرأس، فقال المالكية: يكره مطلقا إلا أن يتضرر.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 52
- Shafi'i
According to the Shafi'is, it is explicitly permissible for the person in iʿtikāf to wear fine clothes, based on the original permissibility.
Applies when: for the person in iʿtikāf wearing fine clothes
The Arabic
وزاد الشافعية التصريح بجواز لبس الثياب الحسنة، لأصل الإباحة.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 52
- Hanbali
According to the Hanbalis, it is recommended for the person in iʿtikāf to refrain from wearing fine clothes and from enjoying what was permissible for him before iʿtikāf, and perfume is disliked for him.
Applies when: for the person in iʿtikāf
The Arabic
وقال الحنابلة: يستحب للمعتكف ترك لبس رفيع الثياب، والتلذذ بما يباح له قبل الاعتكاف، ويكره له الطيب.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 52
- Hanbali
Ahmad (ibn Hanbal) said: 'I do not like that he apply perfume.'
Applies when: for the person in iʿtikāf applying perfume
The Arabic
قال أحمد: لا يعجبني أن يتطيب.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «اعتكاف», paragraph 52