Fiqh · Fasting, Ramadan and Eid
When may a fast be broken, and what follows?
What the four schools of Islamic law hold on breaking a fast, from al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, the Kuwaiti Encyclopedia of Islamic Jurisprudence: 11 views, each with the Encyclopedia's own Arabic words and where they are.
The English is a summary of the Arabic, written with AI and checked against it automatically.
For your own situation, ask a scholar you trust.
The ruling of breaking a fast
In short
- Other scholarsforbidden
- Malikidisliked
- Other scholarsdisliked
- Other scholarsrecommended
- Other scholarspermissible
- Other scholarspermissible
- Majoritypermissible
- Other scholars
Is it forbidden for a person who is obligated to fast to break the fast? The ruling is that it is forbidden, because fasting means refraining from everything that breaks the fast.
Applies when: for anyone who is obligated to fast, especially in Ramadan and in vowed obligatory fasts
The Arabic
الأصل في الإفطار بالنسبة لمن وجب عليه الصوم الحرمة، إذ الصوم معناه الإمساك عن كل ما يفطر. أما بالنسبة لصوم رمضان فظاهر، وأما بالنسبة للصوم الواجب بالنذر فكذلك
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «إفطار», paragraph 2
- Maliki
Is breaking the fast disliked for a traveler who meets the conditions of travel? According to the Malikis, it is disliked, because fasting is better.
Applies when: for a traveler who meets the conditions of travel
The Arabic
كالمسافر الذي تحققت له شرائط السفر، فإنه يجوز له الفطر مع الكراهة عند المالكية
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «إفطار», paragraph 3
- Other scholars
Is breaking the fast disliked for someone who has begun a voluntary fast without an excuse? It is disliked, because of the verse 'Do not invalidate your deeds' and to avoid the view of those who oblige completing it.
Applies when: for one who has begun a voluntary fast without an excuse
The Arabic
وكإفطار من شرع في صوم النفل إن كان بغير عذر
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «إفطار», paragraph 3
- Other scholars
Is breaking the fast recommended when there is an excuse, such as helping a guest eat if it is hard for the host to refrain? It is recommended (mustahabb), not disliked.
Applies when: when there is an excuse, e.g. helping a guest eat if it is hard for the host to refrain
The Arabic
وقد يكون مندوبا: كما لو كان هناك عذر، كمساعدة ضيف في الأكل إذا عز عليه امتناع مضيفه منه أو عكسه، فلا يكره الإفطار بل يستحب
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «إفطار», paragraph 4
- Other scholars
Is breaking the fast permissible for a sick person who does not fear death but fears an increase in illness? It is permissible (mubah).
Applies when: for a sick person who does not fear death but fears an increase in illness
The Arabic
وقد يكون مباحا: كالمريض الذي لا يخشى الهلاك، ولكنه يخشى زيادة المرض
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «إفطار», paragraph 5
- Other scholars
Is breaking the fast permissible for a pregnant woman who fears slight harm to her pregnancy or herself? It is permissible (mubah).
Applies when: for a pregnant woman who fears slight harm to her pregnancy or herself
The Arabic
وكالحامل التي تخاف ضررا يسيرا على حملها أو نفسها
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «إفطار», paragraph 5
- Majority
Is fasting while traveling permissible according to the majority? It is permissible (mubah), though contrary to what is better, based on whether it is considered a concession or an act of resolve.
Applies when: for a traveler, on the basis of considering it a concession or an act of resolve
The Arabic
ومن المباح عند الجمهور الصيام في السفر على خلاف الأفضلية بناء على اعتباره رخصة أو عزيمة
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «إفطار», paragraph 5
Breaking a fast that must be consecutive
In short
- Other scholarsbreaks the fast, consecutiveness is broken, must restart
- Other scholarsdoes not break the fast, consecutiveness is not broken, continues
- Other scholars
If someone breaks a consecutive obligatory fast without an excuse, does the consecutiveness break? Yes, it breaks and he must start over.
Applies when: for one who breaks a consecutive obligatory fast (e.g. expiation for zihar or killing) without an excuse
The Arabic
من أفطر بغير عذر في نهار صوم واجب يجب فيه التتابع، كصوم عن كفارة ظهار أو قتل، انقطع تتابعه ووجب استئنافه
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «إفطار», paragraph 6
- Other scholars
If someone breaks a consecutive obligatory fast with an excuse, does the consecutiveness break? No, it does not break, and he builds on what he has already done.
Applies when: for one who breaks a consecutive obligatory fast with an excuse
The Arabic
فإن كان لعذر فلا ينقطع تتابعه ويبني على ما سبق
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «إفطار», paragraph 6
Making up the fast, and what else follows
In short
- All agreeobligatory to make up
- Other scholarsdisputed
- All agree
Whoever breaks a fast that is obligatory must make it up, and this is agreed upon.
Applies when: breaking a fast in obligatory fasting
The Arabic
يجب القضاء على من أفطر في صيام واجب وهذا باتفاق.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «إفطار», paragraph 7
- Other scholars
There is disagreement about making up a missed voluntary fast.
Applies when: breaking a fast in voluntary fasting
The Arabic
وفي صيام التطوع خلاف.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 5, entry «إفطار», paragraph 7