Fiqh · Fasting, Ramadan and Eid
Can you fast the day of doubt before Ramadan?
What the four schools of Islamic law hold on the day of doubt, from al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, the Kuwaiti Encyclopedia of Islamic Jurisprudence: 21 views, each with the Encyclopedia's own Arabic words and where they are.
The English is a summary of the Arabic, written with AI and checked against it automatically.
For your own situation, ask a scholar you trust.
Overview
In short
- Hanafidefinition of day of doubt
- Malikidefinition of day of doubt
- Malikidefinition of day of doubt
- Shafi'idefinition of day of doubt
- Shafi'idefinition of day of doubt
- Hanbalidefinition of day of doubt
- Hanbalidefinition of day of doubt
- Hanbali (one view)definition of day of doubt
- Hanafi
What is the definition of the day of doubt? The Hanafis hold that the day of doubt is the day when one is uncertain whether it is from Ramadan or from Sha'ban, specifically when people talk about sighting the crescent but it is not confirmed.
Applies when: when people talk about sighting the crescent but it is not confirmed
The Arabic
ذهب الحنفية إلى أن يوم الشك هو اليوم الذي يشك فيه بأنه من رمضان أو من شعبان، وذلك بأن يتحدث الناس بالرؤية ولا تثبت
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 45, entry «يوم الشك», paragraph 2
- Maliki
What is the definition of the day of doubt? The Malikis hold that it is the thirtieth of Sha'ban if the sky is cloudy on its night and sighting is not confirmed.
Applies when: when the sky is cloudy on the night of the thirtieth and sighting is not confirmed
The Arabic
ذهب المالكية إلى أنه يوم الثلاثين من شعبان إذا كانت السماء مغيمة في ليلتها ولم تثبت الرؤية
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 45, entry «يوم الشك», paragraph 2
- Maliki
What is the definition of the day of doubt? Abu al-Hasan (among the Malikis) holds that it is when the sky is cloudy on the night of the thirtieth and sighting is not confirmed, so the morning of that night is the day of doubt.
Applies when: when the sky is cloudy on the night of the thirtieth and sighting is not confirmed
The Arabic
قال أبو الحسن: أن تكون السماء مغيمة ليلة ثلاثين ولم تثبت الرؤية، فصبيحة تلك الليلة هو يوم الشك
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 45, entry «يوم الشك», paragraph 2
- Shafi'i
What is the definition of the day of doubt? The Shafi'is hold that it is the thirtieth of Sha'ban if people talk about sighting it and the sky is clear.
Applies when: when people talk about sighting it and the sky is clear
The Arabic
ذهب الشافعية إلى أن يوم الشك هو يوم الثلاثين من شعبان إذا تحدث الناس برؤيته وكانت السماء مصحية
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 45, entry «يوم الشك», paragraph 2
- Shafi'i
What is the definition of the day of doubt? Al-Mahalli (among the Shafi'is) holds that it is the thirtieth of Sha'ban if people talk about sighting it, meaning the crescent was seen on its night while the sky was clear, and no one testified to it, or children, slaves, or immoral persons testified and their truthfulness was assumed, or a trustworthy person testified but his testimony was not deemed sufficient.
Applies when: when people talk about sighting it, the sky is clear, and testimony is insufficient or from unreliable persons
The Arabic
قال المحلي: وهو يوم الثلاثين من شعبان إذا تحدث الناس برؤيته، أي بأن الهلال رئي ليلته والسماء مصحية ولم يشهد بها أحد أو شهد صبيان أو عبيد أو فسقة وظن صدقهم، أو عدل ولم نكتف به
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 45, entry «يوم الشك», paragraph 2
- Hanbali
What is the definition of the day of doubt? The Hanbalis hold that it is the thirtieth of Sha'ban if there is no obstruction in the sky on its night and people do not look for the crescent.
Applies when: when there is no obstruction in the sky on the night of the thirtieth and people do not look for the crescent
The Arabic
وقال الحنابلة: يوم الشك هو يوم الثلاثين من شعبان إذا لم يكن بالسماء علة ليلة الثلاثين ولم يتراءى الناس الهلال
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 45, entry «يوم الشك», paragraph 2
- Hanbali
What is the definition of the day of doubt? Al-Qadi and most of the Hanbali companions hold that it is also when someone whose testimony is rejected testifies to sighting the crescent.
Applies when: when someone whose testimony is rejected testifies to sighting the crescent
The Arabic
قال القاضي وأكثر الأصحاب من الحنابلة: أو شهد به من ردت شهادته
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 45, entry «يوم الشك», paragraph 2
- Hanbali (one view)
In one Hanbali view, al-Qadi's, the day of doubt is also the 30th of Sha'ban when something in the sky blocks the view.
Applies when: when there is an obstruction in the sky
The Arabic
قال القاضي: أو كان في السماء علة
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 45, entry «يوم الشك», paragraph 2
The ruling of fasting the day of doubt
- Hanafi
According to the Hanafis, fasting on the day of doubt is not permissible for non-supererogatory fasts; if one fasts it for an obligatory fast other than Ramadan, it is disliked and counts for what he fasted if it is not later proven to be from Ramadan; if it is proven to be from Ramadan, it counts for Ramadan in the most sound opinion, provided the faster is a resident; if he is a traveler, it counts absolutely for the obligatory fast he intended.
Applies when: fasting on the day of doubt for a non-supererogatory obligation other than Ramadan, with later proof of being from Ramadan for a resident
The Arabic
قال الحنفية: لا يصام يوم الشك لغير النفل، فإذا صامه عن واجب آخر غير رمضان كره ووقع عما صامه إذا لم تثبت رمضانيته بعد ذلك، فإن ثبتت صح عن رمضان في القول الأصح، إن كان الصائم مقيما، فإن كان مسافرا صح عن الواجب الذي صامه مطلقا.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 45, entry «يوم الشك», paragraph 3
- Hanafi
According to the Hanafis, fasting on the day of doubt as a supererogatory fast is permissible and even recommended for the elite who can be certain of intending it as supererogatory, but disliked for others who hesitate, unless it coincides with a fast they habitually observe, in which case there is no dislike.
Applies when: fasting on the day of doubt as a supererogatory fast, distinguishing between the elite and others, and habitual fasts
The Arabic
أما صومه نفلا، فإن كان الصائم من الخواص- وهم الذين يستطيعون الجزم بصومه نفلا- جاز بل ندب، وإن كان من غير الخواص الذين يترددون في الجزم بصومه نفلا كره، إلا أن يوافق صوما اعتادوه من قبل فلا كراهة
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 45, entry «يوم الشك», paragraph 3
- Maliki
According to the Malikis, fasting on the day of doubt to be cautious for Ramadan is disliked according to the apparent meaning of al-Mudawwanah, and Ibn Abd al-Salam said it is forbidden.
Applies when: fasting on the day of doubt to be cautious for Ramadan
The Arabic
ونص المالكية على أنه لا يصام يوم الشك ليحتاط به من رمضان، فإن صامه كذلك كره على ظاهر المدونة، وقال ابن عبد السلام: حرم
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 45, entry «يوم الشك», paragraph 3
- Maliki
According to the Malikis, if one fasts the day of doubt cautiously and it is later proven to be from Ramadan, it does not count for Ramadan due to lack of definite intention, and he must refrain for the rest of the day out of respect for the month, then make it up after Ramadan.
Applies when: fasting on the day of doubt cautiously, later proven to be from Ramadan
The Arabic
فإن صامه احتياطا ثم ثبت أنه من رمضان لم يجزه عنه، لعدم الجزم في النية، ووجب عليه الإمساك بقية اليوم حرمة للشهر، ثم يقضيه بعد رمضان.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 45, entry «يوم الشك», paragraph 3
- Maliki
According to the Malikis, if one refrains from eating until near midday on the day of doubt and it is then proven to be from Ramadan and he intends it for Ramadan, it does not count for Ramadan and he must make it up after Ramadan because he did not form the intention at dawn.
Applies when: refraining until near midday on the day of doubt, then proven to be from Ramadan and intending it
The Arabic
فإذا أمسك عن الطعام إلى قرب الزوال ثم ثبت أنه من رمضان فنواه عنه لم يجزه عنه، ووجب عليه قضاؤه بعد رمضان أيضا، لأنه لم يبيت فيه النية من الفجر.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 45, entry «يوم الشك», paragraph 3
- Shafi'i
According to the Shafi'is, fasting on the day of doubt is not permissible if it is without a reason; if one fasts it, it is not valid in the most sound opinion, but he may fast it for making up a missed fast or for a vow, and likewise if it coincides with his habitual voluntary fast.
Applies when: fasting on the day of doubt without a reason, or for a missed fast/vow, or coinciding with a habitual fast
The Arabic
ونص الشافعية على أن صوم يوم الشك لا يحل إذا كان بغير سبب، فإذا صامه لم يصح في الأصح، وله صومه عن القضاء والنذر، وكذا لو وافق عادة تطوعه
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 45, entry «يوم الشك», paragraph 3
- Shafi'i
According to al-Isnawi, the well-known position held by the majority of Shafi'is is that fasting on the day of doubt is disliked, not forbidden.
Applies when: fasting on the day of doubt without a reason
The Arabic
قال الإسنوي: المعروف المنصوص الذي عليه الأكثرون: الكراهة لا التحريم
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 45, entry «يوم الشك», paragraph 3
- Other scholars
Is it forbidden to fast on the day of doubt? The relied-upon position in the text is that it is forbidden.
The Arabic
والمعتمد ما في المتن أي التحريم.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 45, entry «يوم الشك», paragraph 3
- Hanbali
Is it disliked to fast on the day of doubt with the intention of Ramadan as a precaution? The Hanbalis state that it is disliked.
Applies when: if one fasts it with the intention of Ramadan as a precaution
The Arabic
ونص الحنابلة على كراهة صوم يوم الشك إذا صامه بنية الرمضانية احتياطا.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 45, entry «يوم الشك», paragraph 3
- Other scholars
What is the ruling on fasting the day of doubt when the sky is clear? According to al-Khiraqi, if twenty-nine days of Sha'ban have passed and the sky is clear, they must not fast that day.
Applies when: when twenty-nine days of Sha'ban have passed and the sky is clear
The Arabic
وقال الخرقي: إذا مضى من شعبان تسعة وعشرون يوما طلبوا الهلال، فإن كانت السماء مصحية لم يصوموا ذلك اليوم
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 45, entry «يوم الشك», paragraph 3
- Other scholars
What is the ruling on fasting the day of doubt when clouds or dust obstruct the sighting? According to al-Khiraqi, if clouds or dust obstruct the sighting, fasting that day is obligatory and it suffices if it turns out to be from Ramadan.
Applies when: when clouds or dust obstruct the sighting
The Arabic
وإن حال دون منظره غيم أو قتر وجب صيامه، وقد أجزأ إذا كان من شهر رمضان.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 45, entry «يوم الشك», paragraph 3
- Hanbali (one view)
What is the ruling on fasting the day of doubt according to one narration from Ahmad? Ibn Qudamah reported that one narration from Ahmad is that the people follow the imam: if the imam fasts they fast, and if he breaks the fast they break it.
Applies when: the people follow the imam
The Arabic
وروي عن أحمد أن الناس تبع للإمام، فإن صام صاموا وإن أفطر أفطروا
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 45, entry «يوم الشك», paragraph 3
- Hanbali (one view)
What is the ruling on fasting the day of doubt according to a third narration from Ahmad? A third narration from Ahmad is that fasting it is not obligatory and it does not suffice for Ramadan if one fasts it.
The Arabic
وعن أحمد رواية ثالثة: لا يجب صومه ولا يجزئه عن رمضان إن صامه.
al-Mawsu'ah al-Fiqhiyyah, volume 45, entry «يوم الشك», paragraph 3